Find Overnight Babysitters in Old Bethpage, NY
At Care.com, your trust and safety are our priority. Compare background-checked overnight babysitters in Old Bethpage, NY and hire the best fit for your family.
Find overnight babysitters in Old Bethpage, NY that you’ll love
60 overnight babysitters are listed in Old Bethpage, NY
The average posted rate is $22/hr as of March 2025
The average experience for nearby overnight babysitters is 9 years
Overnight babysitters in Old Bethpage, NY
Sophia S.
Old Bethpage, NY
$25/hr • 9 yrs exp
I have nine years of experience working with children in various capacities including childcare, tutoring, and directing young actors performing Shakespeare. I recently graduated college (summa cum laude) with a major in psychology and work with individuals who have suffered from traumatic brain injuries.
I enjoy spending time...
Skills:
Special Needs Care
5.0
(2)
Hello. My name is Doreen. I am a mature lady who loves children of all ages. I can cook n do light cleaning and I love playing with the kids! I have a keen sense knowing what is going on all around me so you can rest assure your children will be completely safe with me! I drive excellent and I do have my own vehicle! If it's...
Doreen can also help with: Carpooling, craft assistance, swimming supervision, travel
Skills:
CPR
First Aid
5.0
"Doreen is a warm, loving, funny, responsible and respectful person and sitter. She takes care of my three kids and cooks for them, drives them where they need to go (she has her own car), picks them up at school, plays with them, and loves them. She also runs...
Renni S.
5.0
(2)
Hired by 3 families in your neighborhood
Books Open: Date night/Evening Help
Available Full-time starting July 2025
I've been a career nanny for over 10+ years. I am a mix of Montessori and do-what-works-for-you. I have a wealth of infant and toddler experience and knowledge. I'm pet friendly. CPR certified. Clean driving record.
I am working towards becoming an SLP...
Megan can also help with: Meal prep, light cleaning
Skills:
CPR
First Aid
5.0
"Megan has been watching my daughter and another child since January when both girls were 4 months old. She is an incredible nanny. We only needed her for a temporary position, but I wish we could keep her for longer. She is extremely reliable. She is knowledgeable...
Jessica T.
5.0
(1)
Hired by 2 families in your neighborhood
Hello!
I have been caring for babies and children since I was 12 years of age as a babysitter for my 3 siblings as well as in my neighborhood plus many referrals! I was employed as a camp counselor for children ranging from pre-k up to 4th graders in my teen years. I attended SUNY New Paltz for Art Education. Work experience...
Laura can also help with: Light cleaning, craft assistance, swimming supervision, travel, meal prep
Skills:
Special Needs Care
5.0
"Laura is a wonderful caregiver. My 9 year old son loves having her sit for him. She is interactive, loving, kind, and dependable. She is just fabulous!"
Sally W.
5.0
(1)
Hired by 6 families in your neighborhood
Hi, my current availability is during the afternoon/evenings. I have a degree in Elementary Education and have experience with children of all ages. I like to engage children in things like cooking, reading and arts and crafts.
Animals in the home are an added bonus! I look forward to hearing from you.
Jennifer can also help with: Swimming supervision, meal prep, craft assistance
Skills:
Early Education
4.0
(1)
Hello there! I'm Alyssa and I am 26 years old. I currently have my bachelor's degree in Early Childhood Education. I am working towards getting my master's degree in Special Education pre-k through 12th grade. I have been working with kids for over 9 years. Over the last few years, I've worked in many daycares and preschools. I...
Alyssa can also help with: Craft assistance, light cleaning
Skills:
CPR
Special Needs Care
First Aid
4.0
"Alyssa is a very caring and responsible girl. She takes instruction well, shows patience and is very sweet. Alyssa looked after my little one when she was 1 and did a good job looking after her, feeding her and getting her to nap. She was also playful and...
Maria W.
5.0
(1)
Hired by 2 families in your neighborhood
Hii, my name is Allie and I'm looking to babysit/nanny for anyone in need. I am a college student and I've been babysitting ever since I was 13, I am 20 now. I've always looked after children considering I'm the oldest and even worked in a daycare. I truly love spending time with kids, engaging them in various activities,...
Alexandra can also help with: Swimming supervision, craft assistance, grocery shopping, carpooling
Skills:
Special Needs Care
5.0
"Allie was wonderful with my son and went above and beyond what I required from her. She was very dependable, and my son grew very attached to her and will miss her when school starts. She loves her work and is not just doing this for the money. I would hire her...
Jason B.
5.0
(1)
Hired by 1 family in your neighborhood
I'm a 58 yr old extremely experienced childcare and care giver. I am a single mother of 4 all grown and I would love to help you. I am highly recommended and experienced. Organization is key to success is my motto. This is extremely important when children are concerned. If you need an experienced childcare giver 35 yrs...
Lisamarie can also help with: Craft assistance, swimming supervision, travel, carpooling
Skills:
First Aid
5.0
"I've known Lisa for almost 40 years. I have watched her raise her family basically single handed and all 4 of her young men have turned out to be wonderfully respectful successful men. Lisa has helped me with my children as well while I was experiencing challenges...
Joan M.
5.0
(8)
Hired by 6 families in your neighborhood
My name is Suzanne, but you can call me Suzie! I work FT as a MICA Recovery Program Supervisor, supporting adults w/ Mental Health and Substance Use Disorders. I'm trained in crisis prevention, CPR, Mental Health First Aid, & more-so safety & well-being are always my top priorities.
I spent 4 years as a Level II Child...
Suzanne can also help with: Travel, craft assistance, swimming supervision
Skills:
CPR
Special Needs Care
First Aid
5.0
"Suszi was great my kids loved her she was on time very responsible and trustworthy. We would definitely hire her again. Thank u Suezi! "
Daniel S.
5.0
(1)
Hired by 4 families in your neighborhood
Need a date night babysitter or a after school babysitter? Growing up I watch kids in my neighborhood as their parents went out on date nights or had emergencies they needed to get to. I now help babysit my three nieces who are ages 9, 7, and 5. I lived in California for 6 months to work at PCDA as a Music Therapy Intern. As a...
Dani can also help with: Light cleaning, swimming supervision, carpooling
Skills:
CPR
First Aid
5.0
(1)
Hi, my name is Catherine! I am 32 years old. I have a little over 20 years of child care experience and I am also a mother myself to two sweet and fun loving girls! We love crafting, age appropriate baking and cooking, hands on play, imaginative play, reading, and tons of outdoor fun! I do work in an elementary school part time...
Catherine can also help with: Craft assistance, swimming supervision, carpooling
Skills:
First Aid
CPR
5.0
"Catherine was amazing with our daughter. She is so kind and nurturing. She treated our daughter as if she was one of her own. Catherine is very accommodating and easy-going. I would definitely recommend her to watch your child."
Malissa M.
Brittany D.
Huntington Station, NY
$20-30/hr • 7 yrs exp
3.0
(2)
Hired by 6 families in your neighborhood
Hi I am 23-year-old graduate student at Loyola University Chicago pursuing my Masters in Environmental Science and Sustainable Business! I have been babysitting for the past 7 years from being a daily babysitter to date night babysitter. I have been babysitting kids aging from 3 to 14 and have babysat up to four kids at one...
5.0
"Brittany was great with my 12 year old son. She tutored him from failing school to straight A's. She helped get him into a highly respected private school. I would recommend her to any family. My son really loved her."
Paul R.
5.0
(1)
Hired by 3 families in your neighborhood
Hi! My name is Daria and I am 25 years old. I graduated with a bachelors degree in Childhood Education with a minor in communications and social interactions in 2020! I am currently in my masters program at St. John's University and work at a school as a teacher assistant for grades K-5! So, I'll be spending the rest of my life...
Daria can also help with: Carpooling, travel, swimming supervision, craft assistance
Skills:
Early Education
5.0
"Daria showed up on time and was easy to talk to. We hired her for the month of January while she was home from college to help with our daughter. Very professional! "
Sara M.
5.0
(4)
Hired by 1 family in your neighborhood
Hi! So glad you came to learn more!
Are you struggling with how to ensure your child meets their milestones? Do you have a picky eater? Need help potty training? Too tired to read this because your child is waking constantly at night?
I'm here to help!
I'm a certified teacher. I have 4 teaching certifications (birth-grade 6)...
Skills:
First Aid
Early Education
CPR
5.0
"I have known Kim most of my life and she is a great caring person, my children love her! She is very sweet responsible and knowledgeable in child care. There is no one else id rather have watch my children! "
Lisa M.
Kathy B.
East Meadow, NY
$17/hr • 1 yrs exp
5.0
(1)
I am a mother of three adult boys, ages 29, 28, and 25, and so I am very experienced in child rearing. My first and second son were very close in age, both in diapers at the time, but I Absolutely loved the experience, although hectic at times. My only regret is waiting three years to have my third son. I was able to work part...
Skills:
CPR
5.0
"Kathy is an absolute gem! She is a kind, loving, and wonderful caregiver to our two children and puppy. She goes above and beyond to make sure they are all happy and cares for them like they were family. They love spending time with her!"
Hali G.
5.0
(1)
I worked in a day care and have raised two of my own children. Love to cook, have cooked in daycare and private settings. Responsible, can be flexible with times needed. I currently work as a cook at at church in E Npt in the evenings.
Anne can also help with: Travel, craft assistance, meal prep
5.0
(1)
Hello, my name is Crystal and I am 33 years old. I am a graduate of Long Island University Post Campus with my Bachelor's degree and teaching certification in Childhood Education. I have a Master's Degree and am certified in General and special Education.
I have been teaching for 10 years and have experience working with...
Crystal can also help with: Craft assistance, swimming supervision, travel, carpooling
Skills:
Special Needs Care
First Aid
CPR
5.0
"As a single father of two young girls, finding the right babysitter was of the utmost importance to me. With a busy work schedule that keeps me out of the house more often than I'd like, I needed someone I could trust to not only care for my daughters but also...
Care member
Brittany F.
Bellmore, NY
$20-30/hr • 10 yrs exp
5.0
(5)
Hired by 2 families in your neighborhood
My name is Brittany and I am a licensed educator with a professional degree in Early Childhood Education. I have been working in education professionally for 9 years. I spent my first 6 years in the classroom and my last 3 as the director of a preschool. Currently, I teacher preschool at an Elementary school in Brooklyn. I have...
Brittany can also help with: Travel, craft assistance, carpooling
Skills:
First Aid
Early Education
5.0
"We have known and have been using Brittany for 2 years+ now and my children adore her. She is always on time and is very dependable. She doesn't just WATCH our children, but plays with them and engages them, she is always coming up with games and activities for...
Kace M.
5.0
(2)
Hired by 3 families in your neighborhood
Hi! My name is Amy, I'm 27 and work full time as an accounting associate. On the weekends I teach at a swim school working with multiple toddlers per session. I do like to think of myself as patient, observant and reliable. I also love pets! My family has 4 dogs so I'm used to kids and animals running around! I look forward to...
Amy can also help with: Light cleaning, craft assistance, meal prep, swimming supervision
Skills:
CPR
First Aid
5.0
"We had a great experience with Amy! We would definitely hire her again. My daughter loved her!"
Ellene W.
Yemim S.
Melville, NY
$20/hr • 3 yrs exp
I Am Caring, positive With Over 1 Years Of Experience Working With Children From Ages 2-12 Years Old
5.0
(1)
I am 23years old, currently babysitting And I would love to keep working with kids, am patiently and friendly. I can do date nights , part time , full time, any specials occasion. I would love to hear back from you.
Yemim can also help with: Light cleaning
5.0
"Yemim is a great babysitter, she took care of both of my kids, she’s very responsible, punctual and trustworthy, I still call her every now and then for her care and I have no complaints and my kids love her!!!"
Care member
Showing 1 - 20 of 60
Recent overnight babysitter reviews from local parents in Old Bethpage, NY
Doreen M.
5.0
Doreen is a warm, loving, funny, responsible and respectful person and sitter. She takes care of my three kids and cooks for them, drives them where they need to go (she has her own car), picks them up at school, plays with them, and loves them. She also runs errands for me which is so helpful!...
- Renni S.
Megan J.
5.0
While we have not yet been able to utilize Megan's services for childcare- she has been very accommodating and communicative both during the interview and schedule coordination process. She exudes confidence in her childcare skills and we hope to have her care for our baby in the future.
- Daniel S.
Laura E.
5.0
Laura is a wonderful caregiver. My 9 year old son loves having her sit for him. She is interactive, loving, kind, and dependable. She is just fabulous!
- Sally W.
Alyssa J.
4.0
Alyssa is a very caring and responsible girl. She takes instruction well, shows patience and is very sweet. Alyssa looked after my little one when she was 1 and did a good job looking after her, feeding her and getting her to nap. She was also playful and made it an enjoyable experience for...
- Maria W.
Alexandra F.
5.0
Allie was wonderful with my son and went above and beyond what I required from her. She was very dependable, and my son grew very attached to her and will miss her when school starts. She loves her work and is not just doing this for the money. I would hire her again should I need assistance again.
- Jason B.
Additional Overnight Babysitter Services
Overnight Babysitter Articles
101 indoor games for kids and other activities
March 22nd, 2025 When bad weather keeps kids (and their grown-ups) inside, boredom can quickly set in — but staying indoors doesn’t have to mean missing out on fu... Read more
Easy jokes for kids of all ages
March 21st, 2025 Most kids are little clowns by nature, but learning how to tell a good joke is a skill that they will need help mastering. While your comedic chops may not r... Read more
What is nonbinary gender identity? How to explain to kids (and conscious adults)
March 21st, 2025 Gender diversity has always existed throughout cultures around the world, but in recent years, it’s become a more prominent topic of conversation in ou... Read more
The 3 baby food stages: What foods and when
March 21st, 2025 Making the leap from breast milk or formula to solids and then eventually to table food is an exciting time. But it’s also a little confusing because t... Read more
16 easy fire safety crafts for preschoolers
March 19th, 2025 It may not be as fun a topic as, say, superheroes or unicorns, but discussing fire safety with preschoolers is crucial. According to the ... Read more
FAQs for finding an overnight babysitter near you in Old Bethpage, NY
How can I find an overnight babysitter near me in Old Bethpage, NY that I trust?
Not sure how to find a babysitter near you in Old Bethpage, NY that you can trust to watch your children overnight? You can use Care.com to search for overnight babysitters who can tackle the babysitter duties you need help with and who have an overnight babysitting rate that aligns with your budget. You can search by years of experience and read through reviews from families to get an idea of how trustworthy an overnight babysitter is, but it’s always a good idea to do your own interview and check their references.
How much do you pay a babysitter to stay overnight near me in Old Bethpage, NY?
Overnight babysitters in Old Bethpage, NY start at $22.50, but the exact cost of hiring a babysitter to stay overnight can vary based on each sitter’s years of experience and qualifications.
What babysitter duties do overnight babysitters near me in Old Bethpage, NY take on?
Overnight babysitters can take on a wide variety of babysitter duties. You can search Care.com profiles to find an overnight sitter who can help with tasks like cooking, laundry, light housekeeping, and homework. Review 2 profiles to see which babysitter duties care providers near Old Bethpage, NY feel comfortable tackling.