Find Trusted Cat Sitters Near Me in Bay Shore, NY
Explore background-checked cat sitters in Bay Shore, NY and find loving care for your furry friend.
How it works
Share details about your cat sitter needs
Match with highly rated local cat sitters near you
Compare cat sitter options and choose the best fit
Cat sitters in Bay Shore, NY
Animal Lover all around!
Much experience with both small, large, and extra large dogs.
Experience with cats, rabbits, and small rodents.
Willing to help with reptiles as well.
Will help with transportation of animal, walking, sitting, whatever you need!
Please contact me if interested, be in touch soon!
Taylor can also help with: Pet walking, pet sitting
Hello I'm alexis! All my life I have been very passionate about animals and their care. Being as I was raised around dogs, cats, birds and reptiles, my skills are very versatile. My experience varies from bird sitting, to dog sitting, even fostering kittens! I am currently an online student giving my ample free time to provide...
Alexis can also help with: Pet transportation, pet sitting, pet walking
Jasmine R.
Bay Shore, NY
$25-35/hr • 7 yrs exp
Hi there! I'm a huge pet lover. I am the human to a dog with anxiety and cat that doesn't like to leave the house, so I understand wanting your pets to feel comfortable at home. I can come to your home and visit multiple times or stay for an extended period to keep your little angel company. As long as I have a place to sit and...
Jasmine can also help with: Pet sitting, pet walking
My experience with two dogs and a cat has been incredibly rewarding, deepening my passion for their well-being. Their unique personalities have taught me patience, empathy, and the importance of routine and care. I love animals for their companionship and unconditional love, and I am committed to ensuring they feel safe and...
Carla can also help with: Pet walking, boarding, pet sitting
Hi my names Sophia, I have grown up around animals my whole life from dogs to cats, birds, fish, and lizards. I currently have two french bulldogs that I take care of and watch regularly. I have also had pitbulls, so I am not intimidated by large dogs wether that be sitting or walking them. I love all animals and am willing to...
Sophia can also help with: Pet sitting, pet walking
5.0
(1)
Hired by 1 family in your neighborhood
Welcome! Thanks for taking a look at my profile. I have taken care of friends' cats and dogs for over 10 years. I used to walk neighbor's dogs and take care of their 4 cats. Big or small dogs are welcomed! I have a love for animals and would be excited to meet new animals who possess different traits. I have 6 cats that my...
Marisa can also help with: Pet sitting, pet walking, administration of medicine
5.0
"Marisa is wonderful with my 8 yr old Yorkie Simba! I have never left Simba with any outside caregiver and trust Marisa implicitly to care for him, particularly when I'm away overnight! Simba has special needs and requires special care and medication. I come home...
Liz R.
Cathleen C.
Lindenhurst, NY
$17-20/hr • 10 yrs exp
Experienced Pet Sitter For All Types With Over 10 Years Experience
5.0
(4)
Hired by 3 families in your neighborhood
I have over 10 years of veterinary care with lizards, dogs, cats and horses. I can provide overnight care or daily care and am qualified for administering medications and giving injections. Many many references and disappointed clienst when I relocated to Long Island
Cathleen can also help with: Dog training, pet transportation, pet walking, administration of medicine, pet sitting
5.0
"Cathleen is very professional. She left me references and asked for the number of my veterinarian in case one of my cats got sick while I was away. My cats were well taken care of. I have hired her again."
Megan M.
Angela B.
Deer Park, NY
$17-20/hr • 10 yrs exp
5.0
(1)
Hired by 1 family in your neighborhood
I am a very responsible and caring 32-year-old animal lover and caregiver with over 15 years experience.
I nanny for a toddler part-time and dog/cat sit every chance I get :) I'm currently working on my Masters in Early Childhood and Special Education.
I can provide care in your home or mine. I can also can provide boarding....
Angela can also help with: Pet walking, pet sitting, administration of medicine, boarding
3.0
(2)
Hired by 1 family in your neighborhood
I will take care of your pets when you cannot. I can stop in to feed, walk, and/or play in the yard. I also offer pet sitting in your home when you are away. Let me know what you need! I have 2 boxers and a cat. I've cared for dogs of different types, sizes, ages, etc.
Kathleen can also help with: Administration of medicine, pet sitting, pet transportation, dog training, pet walking
5.0
(1)
I have 5 year of experience. I can help with Pet Transportation and Pet Sitting, and walking. Dog and Cat lover.
Dhariana can also help with: Pet sitting, pet transportation, pet walking
5.0
"Dhariana was amazing when she helped watched my two puppies recently while I was in N. Carolina. She took great care of them & I could tell the dogs loved being around her. I definitely would recommend her services and would do so again. "
Care member
5.0
(2)
Hired by 2 families in your neighborhood
I'm an active animal lover and have been pet-sitting for over 10 years. I have a number of pet-sitting clients in the Huntington and Oyster Bay areas and love spending my time with the animals I watch. Outside of pet-sitting, my full-time job is as the Hospital Supervisor for a non-profit wildlife hospital where I oversee the...
Lauren can also help with: Pet sitting, administration of medicine, boarding, daily feeding, pet walking
5.0
"Lauren took care of our lovely cat while we were away for 4 days. Our cat has special needs, therefore, Lauren's work was challenging. However, she has proven to be the greatest pet sitter we have ever known. She is very responsible and reliable: Each day we...
Ceylan C.
5.0
(2)
Hired by 1 family in your neighborhood
I have officially been a paid pet sitter. My family and friends always counted on me for love and care of all their pets. I walked, fed, played with all of them. Since I was a child I had dogs and cats. I adore animals, who were my family. Recently, I lost my last dog, a Westie, the most lovable little boy. I have watched golden...
Sharon can also help with: Pet walking, pet sitting, administration of medicine
5.0
"I have know Sharon all my life and have witnessed her with her own pets. Believe me when I tell you they were always her babies!! There is no doubt in my mind that she will treat your pet the same way."
Karen L.
5.0
(11)
Hired by 2 families in your neighborhood
My name is Stacey. My love for pets is what sparked me to enter the wonderful world of pet setting. I grew up with animals my entire life and have a passion for dogs and cats. I am excited to be able to help you by caring for your pets while you are away. Your babies will be cared for and loved just as if they were my own. I...
Stacey can also help with: Boarding, pet sitting
5.0
"I am disabled. Stacey walks my dog just as I ask. Even better than I ask. She is reliable, prompt, cautious, makes good decisions regarding weather, heat, his health. She is a dream come true! Boston Terriers with their flat faces must be taken out in real feel...
Care member
5.0
(2)
Hired by 2 families in your neighborhood
Passionate pet sitter with experience caring for a variety of animals, including dogs, cats, and exotic pets. Adept at providing exercise, feeding, and administering medication. I have a cat that needs daily meds and have no problem getting her to take it . I am Reliable and trustworthy with a commitment to providing the highest...
Lisa can also help with: Pet walking, pet transportation, pet sitting
5.0
"Lisa took care of our cats for several days, and did an outstanding job. We came home to cats that were very happy and clearly well cared for. She is reliable, kind, and clearly loves animals. We will definitely be asking her to care for our kitties again in the...
Kelly T.
5.0
(4)
Hired by 1 family in your neighborhood
I'm very reliable caring and experienced In all types of care . I'm experienced in all kinds of pets such as birds fish dogs cats .
Andrea can also help with: Pet sitting, dog training, grooming, administration of medicine, boarding, pet walking & more
5.0
"Hired Andrea to take care of my two cats while I was out of town. My cats love her! I will definitely be using her again when I go on my next trip!"
Gina C.
5.0
(18)
Hired by 4 families in your neighborhood
Hi! I'm Valerie and would love to meet you and your fur baby! A little about me I graduated in May with my MBA from Hofstra University and adopted my dog Meeko two years ago from a town shelter. I'm an avid volunteer for One Love Dog Rescue and just love pets (cats too!) :)
As a sitter I created an intake form where I take...
Valerie can also help with: Pet sitting, pet walking, pet transportation
5.0
"Valerie is amazing with our 2 dogs. She came highly recommended from multiple people. We travel a lot and knowing we have her to watch our 2 dogs is a huge relief for us.
Our dogs absolutely love her and get very excited to see her."
Denise P.
5.0
(1)
Hello my name is Julia!
I'm a 23 years old who work in my family's business in the food industry. since I was young I have always had dogs big and small. Currently, I have one dogs and two rescue kittens. As far as my experience goes, I am the go to in my family to sit any pets. I am a very active person that will engage your...
Julia can also help with: Pet walking, pet sitting
5.0
"Julia was amazing with my dog and cat! Really reliable!"
Jamie K.
Brooke V.
Commack, NY
$17-25/hr • 10 yrs exp
5.0
(1)
Hi, I'm Brooke! I love animals so much and have 10 years of experience watching both cats and dogs! I can help with pet sitting, walking, and transportation. I am very reliable and organized, and I will love your pet as if it is my own!
Brooke can also help with: Pet sitting, pet transportation, pet walking
5.0
"Brooke is amazing. We left our dog for the first time to go on vacation and couldn’t have chosen anybody better to stay with her. Not only did she do every single thing we asked, she sent us daily photos, and even worked on some light training! I highly recommend...
Care member
5.0
(1)
Hired by 1 family in your neighborhood
Hi! My name is Lisa! I have a lifetime of experience with animals. I adore all types of animals. I am a mother of 4 grown children so my schedule is quite flexible. I have 2 dogs and 3 cats. I also cared Golden Retrievers for years. Three of the pups became service dogs. Walking is a big hobby of mine, and over the years, I have...
Lisa can also help with: Pet walking, boarding, pet sitting, daily feeding, pet transportation, administration of medicine & more
5.0
(1)
I am a professional woman who lives and works locally. I have a cat and a dog of my own. I have worked with dogs and cats of all sizes and ages. I will love yours like I do my own. I am a notary so I am security cleared.
Jill can also help with: Pet walking, pet transportation
Showing 1 - 20 of 60
Recent cat sitter reviews from local pet parents in Bay Shore, NY
Marisa O.
5.0
Marisa is wonderful with my 8 yr old Yorkie Simba! I have never left Simba with any outside caregiver and trust Marisa implicitly to care for him, particularly when I'm away overnight! Simba has special needs and requires special care and medication. I come home and he's happy, fed, and well cared...
- Liz R.
Cathleen C.
5.0
Cat is wonderful not only helps with my pup but also with errands etc. I am disabled and she is a god send. Thankful to have found her.
- Stacey S.
Dhariana D.
5.0
Dhariana was amazing when she helped watched my two puppies recently while I was in N. Carolina. She took great care of them & I could tell the dogs loved being around her. I definitely would recommend her services and would do so again.
- Care member
Lauren S.
5.0
Lauren took care of our lovely cat while we were away for 4 days. Our cat has special needs, therefore, Lauren's work was challenging. However, she has proven to be the greatest pet sitter we have ever known. She is very responsible and reliable: Each day we received a call from her about how our...
- Ceylan C.
Sharon W.
5.0
I have know Sharon all my life and have witnessed her with her own pets. Believe me when I tell you they were always her babies!! There is no doubt in my mind that she will treat your pet the same way.
- Karen L.
Additional Cat Sitter Services
Cat Sitter Articles
Overnight pet sitting rates and what’s included in the cost
March 25th, 2025 From shift work to vacations to family emergencies, there are many circumstances in which overnight pet sitting is crucial.
“Pet parents of
... Read more
My dog’s stomach is gurgling! Causes, concerns and when to see a vet
March 19th, 2025 At its most severe, it can sound like a freight train moving through your living room. When it’s mild, it chugs more like a small model train. We&rsquo... Read more
7 best guard dogs for families
March 19th, 2025 A pet can add a sense of security to any home. The simple idea of having another living, breathing thing in your house has a way of doing that. Some families... Read more
11 homemade cat treats your kitty will love
March 18th, 2025 Dogs will do just about anything for a treat. Cats? Not so much. Even still, it’s nice to have cat treats in your arsenal for birthdays, special occasi... Read more
6 signs you need a cat sitter
October 15th, 2022 It’s a common stereotype that cats like to be left alone. And while your cat may have their moments of aloofness, make no mistake — they do need ... Read more
FAQs for finding cat sitters near you in Bay Shore, NY
How much does a cat sitter cost near me in Bay Shore, NY?
Hiring a cat sitter near you in Bay Shore, NY through Care.com will cost an average of $19.40 per hour as of April, 2025. This rate will vary depending on the level of care you need for your cat, the number of cats you have, and the total amount of hours or days your cat sitter will need to come to your home. Some cat sitters will charge a fixed rate per day if full-time care is requested.
How can I find a local cat sitter near me in Bay Shore, NY?
You can filter and sort local cat sitter profiles near you in Bay Shore, NY. Compare your options by reading about their experience, the hourly rate they charge, and reviews from other cat parents. There are currently 5 cat sitters in Bay Shore, NY, although you can expand the radius of your search if you'd like to increase your options.
What questions should I ask a cat sitter in an interview near me in Bay Shore, NY?
The best cat sitters near you in Bay Shore, NY have a combination of experience and passion for cat care. Ask questions about the types of pets they have personally owned and how often they are currently cat sitting. Because cats behave differently than dogs, make sure to ask questions that are specific to cat behaviors and tendencies. It's also a good idea to give specific scenarios to the cat sitter you're speaking to so you can have a good idea of how they will treat your cat when they are in your home. Be sure to ask for references from other cat parents in Brooklyn that have worked with the sitter of your preference.
Is it safe to leave my cat with a cat sitter near me in Bay Shore, NY?
It can be safe to leave your cat with a cat sitter near you in Bay Shore, NY if you take the necessary precautions such as researching their qualifications, conducting interviews and requesting references from previous clients. You should also ensure that they carry adequate insurance coverage just in case something unexpected happens while they’re caring for your pet. Finally, be sure to communicate clearly with your cat sitter about any specific needs or routines your pet may have so they can provide the best possible care while you’re away.
How experienced are cat sitters near me in Bay Shore, NY?
When looking for a cat sitter near you in Bay Shore, NY, you can find cat sitters with a wide variety of experience. Many cat sitters are passionate about working with animals and have years of experience caring for cats in both professional and personal settings. You can review different cat sitter profiles on Care.com to learn more about their different experience levels.