Find Babysitters in Shelter Island, NY
At Care.com, your trust and safety are our priority. Compare background-checked babysitters in Shelter Island, NY and hire the best fit for your family.
Find babysitters in Shelter Island, NY that you’ll love
60 babysitters are listed in Shelter Island, NY
The average posted rate is $22/hr as of March 2025
The average experience for nearby babysitters is 6 years
Babysitters in Shelter Island, NY
5.0
(1)
Hired by 2 families in your neighborhood
Hello! My name is Rowan, and I'm 24 years old. I have 8+ years of experience in childcare, and adore working with children and seeing them flourish and grow! I'm currently attending school and commuting into NYC, but will only be away for 2 days a week. Other than that, I'm available and eager to see if I'd be a good fit for you...
Rowan can also help with: Swimming supervision, travel, craft assistance, meal prep, carpooling, light cleaning & more
Skills:
First Aid
CPR
5.0
"Rowan is a delightful person and a wonderful nanny. She is hard working, reliable, and thoughtful and our daughters adore her. "
Gabrielle F.
I've been a part time babysitter for several families in New York for my parent's friends. I am taking some time off from college, so I have a wide open schedule. Most importantly, I am a cheerful person and I always try to have fun with the children.
Nicholas can also help with: Craft assistance, swimming supervision, travel, grocery shopping, meal prep
Skills:
CPR
First Aid
Hello, I am an islander, trying to find a loving family to take care of her/his children, a 30-year-old adult, responsible, kind, affectionate, I like to be dynamic with children, teach them good manners, teach them to speak Spanish, prepare their healthy food and keep them safe.
friendly. dynamic. tidy
I like working with...
Madeline K.
Greenport, NY
$17-19/hr • 3 yrs exp
5.0
(3)
I've been babysitting since I was 11 years old and am trained in first aid and CPR. I'm a mother of 1 baby and a big sister to 4. I love playing with kid's by entering their world through games and activities.
Madeline can also help with: Light cleaning
Skills:
CPR
First Aid
5.0
"Maddy is so sweet and really good with kids. She's very patient and takes her time to listen to your kids/ your needs. She's very punctual and takes her job serious. I have no complaints about Madeline I would hire her to watch my kids any day!"
Elizabeth M.
Gaby A.
East Hampton, NY
$10-15/hr • 8 yrs exp
5.0
(2)
Hired by 15 families in your neighborhood
I'm a Pace University graduate with 6 years of experience in babysitting children with ages ranging from 6 months old to 13-year-olds. I'm patient and comfortable supervising children and providing a variety of activities to keep the children mentally and physically engaged and entertained.
Gaby can also help with: Swimming supervision
5.0
"Sandra is such a kind, caring, wonderful person. She showed up with a smile on her face and was willing to do whatever we needed her. Our 9 month old loved her and took to her immediately. We were visiting from out of town, and she made it so easy for us to feel...
Caroline D.
5.0
(2)
Hired by 9 families in your neighborhood
As a friendly and approachable childcare provider with 20 years of experience, I am passionate about supporting families and offering dependable care for up to four children, ranging from infants to preteens. Throughout my career, I have completed early childhood development coursework, am a certified teacher, and hold...
Jenifer can also help with: Travel
Skills:
First Aid
CPR
5.0
(4)
Hired by 11 families in your neighborhood
Hi, my name is Elizabeth and I just finished my MBA in Public Accounting at Pace University. I have over 10 years of experience in babysitting and have excellent references. I have a valid NY drivers license and have experience with kids of all ages. I have grown up in East Hampton my whole life and know the area very well.
Elizabeth can also help with: Grocery shopping, carpooling, travel, meal prep, swimming supervision, light cleaning & more
5.0
"Elizabeth was wonderful, very polite and responsible. Would hire her again! "
Care member
5.0
(2)
Hired by 5 families in your neighborhood
Hi my name is Martha. I live in East Hampton, I love to be a nanny , I love babies and children , I have a lot of patience with them, I enjoy playing games, story time, spend time with them outside. etc. and I am very patient and kind , I have my own car, a clean driving license, references and 10 years of experience. I am very...
Martha can also help with: Travel, grocery shopping, light cleaning
Skills:
CPR
5.0
"Working with Martha was a true gift this summer! Our two year old daughter was rather clingy because she'd spent so much time with me over quarantine... As a mother herself, Martha displayed empathy, kindness, caution and cleanliness every day.
When our daughter...
Kaitlin M.
4.6
(5)
Hired by 7 families in your neighborhood
I'm from Colombia, i used to be a teacher there; I've more than 10 years experience working and caring for children... I'm kind, respectful; patient; responsible, i can teach them Spanish and helping with homework.
Sandra can also help with: Craft assistance, light cleaning, swimming supervision, carpooling
Skills:
First Aid
CNA
CPR
5.0
"Sandra as friendly, easy to work with, and our 3 kids had a great time with her (ages 7, 5 and 5). We would definitely recommend her and hire her again!"
Cristina J.
5.0
(2)
Hired by 7 families in your neighborhood
Hello, my name is Colleen. I first joined Care. com while taking care of my then 19-month-old niece a few days a week for my twin who is a teacher. I worked for the school system in town for 4 and a half years, mostly special education and loved it. I started nannying at age 13 and have been babysitting on and off over the...
Colleen can also help with: Light cleaning, craft assistance, meal prep, swimming supervision, carpooling
Skills:
CPR
First Aid
Early Education
5.0
"Colleen is amazing! She is fun, loving, caring and dependable. We are so lucky we hired her."
Meredith C.
Yamilier C.
Sag Harbor, NY
$30-45/hr • 6 yrs exp
4.9
(10)
Hired by 10 families in your neighborhood
Hello my name is Yamilier. I live in Sag Harbor, NY. I'm a Newborn Care Specialist, I help out with overnight sleep conditioning and 24/7 as well. I'm CPR Certified and have a lot of experience with infants, I work with companies. I'm vaccinated and have flue shots as well as TDAP vaccinated. I have my own car. I'm fun and...
Yamilier can also help with: Light cleaning, swimming supervision, craft assistance, travel, carpooling, meal prep & more
Skills:
Special Needs Care
First Aid
CPR
5.0
"Yami has watched our 9 month old son several times, starting when he was 6 months old, and I would highly recommend her. She is kind, patient and very engaged. She is excellent with infants."
Tania R.
5.0
(4)
Hired by 4 families in your neighborhood
Newborn specialist
Mother of two
Responsible babysitter with experience
Fully vaccinated (COVID)
Reliable
Flexible
Non-smoker
Comfortable with pets
Have my own transportation
CPR certified
Willing to help with light housekeeping
Willing to drive children
Clean background
English/Spanish
Madelin can also help with: Light cleaning, travel, craft assistance, meal prep
Skills:
CPR
First Aid
5.0
"Madelin was great with our kids. She was kind, prompt, and very capable. We would definitely recommend her!"
Bekah M.
My name is Stefany, I work as a teaching assistant at one of the local schools. I have been working with children in a variety of settings.
Stefany can also help with: Craft assistance, swimming supervision
Skills:
Special Needs Care
Evelyn M.
East Hampton, NY
$25/hr • 7 yrs exp
Experienced Babysitter Available Weekends And Some Week Days
Hired by 1 family in your neighborhood
I am a healthcare graduate looking for a job while I study for my boards. I have extensive experience babysitting children and truly enjoy it. I have been caring for my sibling since he was a newborn, which has given me invaluable hands-on experience. I love engaging with kids, playing with them, and teaching them new things....
Evelyn can also help with: Swimming supervision, craft assistance, carpooling
Ariany M.
East Hampton, NY
$20-50/hr • 2 yrs exp
I'm passionate about nurturing the growth and development of children. With over two years of experience as a childcare provider, I've had the privilege of positively impacting the lives of many kids. My patient and calm nature, coupled with my creative and imaginative approach, makes me a great fit for caring for your...
Rosie F.
East Hampton, NY
$25-50/hr • 9 yrs exp
Hello! My name is Rosie, and I'm an experienced caregiver hoping to continue working with kids after recently graduating Summa Cum Laude from U. C. Berkeley. I have nine years of experience caring for kids of all ages. I am CPR and First Aid certified.
My creative and imaginative nature makes playtime fun and engaging for...
Rosie can also help with: Swimming supervision, light cleaning, meal prep, craft assistance, grocery shopping
Skills:
First Aid
CPR
Special Needs Care
Leslie F.
East Hampton, NY
$30-50/hr • 5 yrs exp
Hired by 3 families in your neighborhood
I've spent the past five years providing reliable childcare to families in my community. As a nurturing and experienced caregiver, I have a passion for supporting families and ensuring the well-being and safety of children. My calm and patient demeanor, combined with my creativity and imagination, allows me to connect with...
Leslie can also help with: Light cleaning, grocery shopping, travel, meal prep, carpooling, swimming supervision & more
Skills:
Special Needs Care
Early Education
CPR
Hired by 1 family in your neighborhood
Hi! I am a fun and energetic 24-year-old looking for a full-time nanny position while I continue my education with part-time night classes. I graduated from The University of Tampa in August 2023 with a Bachelor of Science in Allied Health and a concentration in medical sciences. I have 8 years of experience caring for children...
Julia can also help with: Craft assistance, meal prep, carpooling, light cleaning, swimming supervision, grocery shopping & more
Skills:
CPR
First Aid
I am 20 years old. I am currently taking a year out of University of St. Andrews after completing my first year there. I am reliable, intelligent, and responsible. I can drive and have my own transportation. I have been babysitting for a long time, as I have a huge Irish family. For two summers I worked as a camp counselor in...
Hired by 1 family in your neighborhood
I live in Greenport, New York and I have experience with children from ages 6 months and up. I have 6 years of experience working with children, and have grown up around children. I hold a Bachelors Degree in Psychology and Masters Degree in Social Work, and I work part-time as a social worker. I am currently working toward a...
Melanie can also help with: Meal prep, craft assistance, light cleaning, grocery shopping, swimming supervision
Skills:
CPR
Special Needs Care
Showing 1 - 20 of 60
Recent babysitter reviews from local parents in Shelter Island, NY
Rowan P.
5.0
Rowan is a delightful person and a wonderful nanny. She is hard working, reliable, and thoughtful and our daughters adore her.
- Gabrielle F.
Madeline K.
5.0
Maddy is so sweet and really good with kids. She's very patient and takes her time to listen to your kids/ your needs. She's very punctual and takes her job serious. I have no complaints about Madeline I would hire her to watch my kids any day!
- Elizabeth M.
Gaby A.
5.0
Sandra was awesome. She has a very kind disposition and it wasn’t even 3 min after she arrived that my 3 year old grabbed her hand to go play. I was so grateful because it was our first time using a babysitter my daughter didn’t already know. 😅 Sandra also watched our very active 14 month old and...
- Care member
Elizabeth T.
5.0
Elizabeth watched our 6-month-old while we went to dinner. She was on time and did a great job watching the baby and calming him down when he cried.
- Care member
Martha U.
5.0
Martha is the best. She took care of our son from the time he was 5 months old until he was 2. She is so incredibly patient, kind, caring, warm, nurturing, creative and loving. She is also extremely communicative, trustworthy and careful. As a first-time mom, I was incredibly nervous to leave my...
- Elizabeth F.
Additional Babysitter Services
Babysitter Articles
How to get CPR and first-aid certified
March 27th, 2024 It’s not fun to think about emergencies. But as much as you hope they’ll never happen, you do have to be prepared. CPR and first-aid are things ... Read more
Best exercises for kids (ages 5-12 years old)
February 12th, 2025 Kids need designated time each day to get out their wiggles and bump their heartbeats up a notch. According to the ... Read more
International Women’s Day for kids: How to explain the holiday to children of all ages
February 27th, 2025 Try this quick experiment with your kids: Without any context, ask them to name a handful of historic figures they’ve learned about recently in school. ... Read more
Restaurants where kids eat free (or super cheap)
May 15th, 2024 After a long workday or busy weekend, sometimes the prospect of cooking for the whole family (and especially cleaning up) just sounds exhausting. But going ... Read more
Easy jokes for kids
April 11th, 2024 Most kids are little clowns by nature, but learning how to tell a good joke is a skill that they will need help mastering. While your comedic chops may not ... Read more
FAQs for finding a babysitter in Shelter Island, NY:
How can I find a Shelter Island babysitter near me?
Figuring out how to find a babysitter in Shelter Island, NY can feel overwhelming at first. To make your search easier, you can use Care.com to search through the profiles of babysitters near you. You can review 3 babysitters in Shelter Island, NY on Care.com, with an average rating of 5.0. Once you choose candidates that fit your needs, you can contact them to schedule interviews, check references, and request additional background checks.
How much do babysitters charge in Shelter Island, NY?
The average rate for Shelter Island, NY babysitters on Care.com is $22.33 per hour as of March 2025. How much a babysitter charges can vary greatly depending on location, years of experience, the desired babysitter duties, and how many children will need looking after. The cost of care can also be influenced by special needs such as overnight care. You can use the Care.com childcare calculator to help you calculate your child care costs.
What type of babysitter services can I find near me in Shelter Island, NY?
You can find all kinds of babysitters in Shelter Island, NY through Care.com. As of 2025, you can browse caregivers that specialize in a range of duties, from overnight and infant care, to weekend and after school babysitters. Alongside keeping an eye on your children, caregivers can provide a variety of babysitting duties. They can help with homework or can possibly take on more extensive tutoring responsibilities, can drive your children to school or activities, and can spend time playing with them or helping them get their chores done. When you interview potential sitters, ask them what babysitting duties they are happy to take on.