Care.com logo
Child CareTutoringSenior CarePet CareHousekeeping

Find a job

Find after school babysitters in New Berlin, WI that you’ll love

60 after school babysitters are listed in New Berlin, WI

The average posted rate is $15/hr as of April 2025

The average experience for nearby after school babysitters is 6 years

After school babysitters in New Berlin, WI

Mikayla H.'s Photo

Mikayla H.


New Berlin, WI

$15-20/hr10 yrs exp

After School Nanny Or Date Night Babysitter? I've Got You Covered!

See profile
Hello and welcome to my page! I am Mikayla and I have many years of experience caring for children ages 6 weeks-13 years! I have my bachelors degree in psychology with an emphasis in development and minor on education, I have all the course work to be a teacher but never student taught. I am currently pursuing my Masters degree...
Mikayla can also help with: Travel, swimming supervision, light cleaning, craft assistance, carpooling
Skills:

Special Needs Care

CPR

First Aid

Jillian S.'s Photo

Jillian S.


New Berlin, WI

$10-50/hr3 yrs exp

High-school Graduate Looking To Expand My Experience In Child Care

I started working with kids when I was a freshman in high school I babysat for family friends and when I was a sophomore I got a job at lifetime fitness In the kids academy. In my spare time, I like to spend lots of time outdoors with friends and family. I grew up camping with family and have grown up really liking outdoor...
Libby R.'s Photo

Libby R.


New Berlin, WI

$15-25/hr4 yrs exp

Genuine, Trustworthy, And Down-right FUN Nanny!

Starting in undergrad, I became interested in working with kids to promote healthy and active lives. I was a summer camp counselor for kids (between the ages of 5-15) for three years at the University of Minnesota. Within the camp, activities, skills, and games were constantly and uniquely provided. After graduation, I moved to...
Libby can also help with: Carpooling, travel, craft assistance, swimming supervision
Skills:

First Aid

CPR

Leah L.'s Photo

Leah L.


New Berlin, WI

$18-25/hr5 yrs exp

Leah L

As a freshman college student, I am eagerly seeking opportunities to provide care as a summer nanny or as a reliable last-minute sitter. With a solid foundation in childcare since the age of 14, coupled with diverse experience with kids as a summer camp counselor, babysitter/nanny, and dance teacher across Wisconsin, I bring a...
Leah can also help with: Carpooling, swimming supervision, craft assistance, light cleaning, grocery shopping, meal prep & more
Skills:

First Aid

CPR

Special Needs Care

Maria S.'s Photo

Maria S.


New Berlin, WI

$12-16/hr3 yrs exp

Dependable, Caring Provider

Hello! My name is Maria, I am 18 years old. I have over 3 years of experience babysitting and I am looking for something more permanent over the next two and a half months. I have availability Mondays, Wednesdays, and Fridays.
Maria can also help with: Meal prep, light cleaning, swimming supervision, craft assistance
Skills:

CPR

First Aid

Olivia D.'s Photo

Olivia D.


New Berlin, WI

$16-20/hr10 yrs exp

Caring And Fun Sitter.

Hello, my name is Olivia Barnes. I am a students at UW Milwaukee studying social work. I have 10 years of experience. I can help with Travel and Errands.
Olivia can also help with: Travel, craft assistance, swimming supervision, carpooling
Skills:

CPR

Special Needs Care

First Aid

Heather K.'s Photo

Heather K.


New Berlin, WI

$20/hr7 yrs exp

Fun For Mess Makers And Little Movers!

Hired by 1 family in your neighborhood

One thing you should know about me is that I was an Assistant Teacher at Little Light Of Mine. I worked here for over a year with many different ages! I love making art and teaching math; as well as cleaning (which is honestly fun I love to deep clean). I hope you choose me to take care of your children because it honestly makes...
Heather can also help with: Craft assistance, light cleaning, swimming supervision, carpooling, meal prep
Skills:

Special Needs Care

First Aid

CPR

Brittany B.'s Photo

Brittany B.


New Berlin, WI

$10-25/hr10 yrs exp

Ultimate Babysitter!

5.0

(2)

Hired by 2 families in your neighborhood

Hey! I'm Brittany! I absolutely adore kids! I grew up with more than 30 cousins. Family events are always crazy. With conversations flowing, kids playing, and food flying, our family has become close and always there for each other, through the madness. Taking into consideration that I grew up caring for my cousins, I have many...
Brittany can also help with: Carpooling, light cleaning, travel, swimming supervision, meal prep, craft assistance & more
Skills:

CPR

First Aid

5.0
"Brittany was great with my boys and she always cleaned up the house while watching the kids. I am sad that she moved away and will miss her! She is very reliable and truly great with kids!"

Laci M.

Sam S.


New Berlin, WI

$15-20/hr3 yrs exp

Fun And Creative Sitter For All Walks Of Life

Hello, My name is Sam and I have worked with children for over 3 years in a variety of ways. My experience lies in camp counseling, baby sitting, kayak/ canoe instructing, rock climbing teaching, and being a swim instructor. I love art and drawing and can teach for free as a fun activity. Other than that I also love the outdoors...
Sam can also help with: Grocery shopping, meal prep, light cleaning
Skills:

First Aid

CPR

Hired by 1 family in your neighborhood

I'd describe my personality as patient, fun and caring. In my spare time, I like to spend time with my own family.
Hannah K.'s Photo

Hannah K.


Milwaukee, WI

$10-15/hr4 yrs exp

Hired by 5 families in your neighborhood

Lots of experience! One day care, three families, before and after school program)! I am looking for either part or full time work! I used to work for rogers behavioral health!
Hannah can also help with: Carpooling, craft assistance, light cleaning, meal prep
Skills:

CNA

CPR

Early Education

Alexis G.'s Photo

Alexis G.


Milwaukee, WI

$20/hr8 yrs exp

Engaged And Fun Sitter

Hired by 3 families in your neighborhood

I graduated from UCLA in 2019! I recently moved to Milwaukee as I am a Medical Student at the Medical College of Wisconsin. I love kids and am CPR certified. I am currently pursuing my MD with hopes to enter into Pediatrics. I have 8 years of babysitting/ nannying experience!
Alexis can also help with: Grocery shopping, travel, craft assistance, swimming supervision, carpooling, light cleaning & more
Skills:

First Aid

CPR

5.0
"Lexi is an AMAZING caregiver! She is quickly responsive, great communication, punctual, friendly, and helpful. She has watched our son a few times now and was so attentive and caring to him and his special needs! And he loves spending time with her so it makes...

Care member

Cam W.'s Photo

Cam W.


Elm Grove, WI

$18/hr9 yrs exp

College Student (afternoon/evening Availability)

Hired by 6 families in your neighborhood

I have 9 years of experience. I can help with travel and light housekeeping. I have experience with all ages of kids and I have lots of experience with taking care of multiple children at once. I work full time as a tax accountant at CliftonLarsonAllen, but have lots of evening availability after work. I would love to find a...
Cam can also help with: Carpooling, light cleaning
Skills:

CPR

5.0
"Our family has been so fortunate to have Cam as our babysitter for for our 2 year old daughter. She was a life-saver when we were in a pinch. We hired her for the 1st time when we were in need of emergency childcare. Since then she has babysit for us on other...

Marianne J.

Katherine E.'s Photo

Katherine E.


Franklin, WI

$12-17/hr4 yrs exp

Hi! I am the third born of seven children. My parents have opened their home to children in the foster care system. Since the age of 13, I have been exposed to and worked with children ranging from premature newborns to troubled teenagers. I am a student at MATC studying education to pave the way to my future as a teacher....
Katherine can also help with: Light cleaning, meal prep, craft assistance
Skills:

Special Needs Care

5.0
"Katie is very dependable and loyal babysitter. She's attentive to children of all ages. I have two children ages two and seven and they have loved her from the beginning and they always look forward to seeing her. She continuously encourages intellectual and...

Emily H.

Rachel R.'s Photo

Rachel R.


Milwaukee, WI

$22-35/hr10 yrs exp

Seasoned Nanny/Childcare Provider

Hired by 1 family in your neighborhood

I started babysitting children at age 11, after taking a certified babysitting course, and being trained in First Aid/CPR. I have done nannying and babysitting jobs most of my life, and I am currently nannying for 6-mo-old boy/girl twins. Previously, I served in a household manager role. I nannied for 6 families during graduate...
Rachel can also help with: Travel, craft assistance
Skills:

CPR

First Aid

Special Needs Care

5.0
"Rachel has extensive experience in caring for children of all ages and stages, including children with special needs. She excels at identification of a child's needs and customizes her approach and care provided based on this. She places high focus on...

Care member

Elle M.'s Photo

Elle M.


Milwaukee, WI

$18-25/hr8 yrs exp

Hi! I'm Elle. I've been nannying for just under 1 year, have been babysitting for 8, and also worked at a daycare for a year. I am currently in the Milwaukee area and available for date nights and weekends! I have experience with all ages (4 weeks - 10 years) and experience with multiple children. My favorite part about nannying...
Elle can also help with: Carpooling, light cleaning, travel, swimming supervision, meal prep, craft assistance & more
Skills:

CPR

First Aid

5.0
"Elle watched our 3 girls for us for around a year before moving away and she was amazing with our girls. Definitely recommend :)"

Care member

Deirdre S.'s Photo

Deirdre S.


Waukesha, WI

$19-21/hr10 yrs exp

Hired by 3 families in your neighborhood

For the last 21/2 + years, I've worked with 2 families with teenagers on the autism spectrum. I love working with them, leaving the full-time position due to circumstances out of my control. ( Would elaborate more but in private.) Before was private nanny 3 years, family moved out of state for work. I have many references. Home...
Deirdre can also help with: Meal prep, craft assistance, light cleaning, travel, swimming supervision
Skills:

Special Needs Care

5.0
"Deirdre has been w/ us over 2 yrs! She's punctual. She never cancels on us. She is all HEART, she is loyal. My family has extenuating circumstances + she goes with the flow so WELL!"

Care member

Cierra S.'s Photo

Cierra S.


Milwaukee, WI

$22-30/hr9 yrs exp

Hired by 4 families in your neighborhood

Hello, I am Cierra. 26 years old and love children and animals! I am currently a K4 teacher at Milwaukee Spanish Immersion. I have been a teacher for four years. Prior to teaching I was an in home therapist for children with ASD for 4 years. I have experience with babysitting, nannying, and teaching, and respite care for...
Cierra can also help with: Grocery shopping, meal prep, light cleaning, swimming supervision, craft assistance
Skills:

First Aid

CPR

Early Education

5.0
"Cierra has such a happy and bubbly personality that made me so comfortable welcoming her into my home. She did an amazing job and I would definitely hire her again."

Zipporah S.

Alaina C.'s Photo

Alaina C.


Greendale, WI

$10-20/hr6 yrs exp

Part-Time Caregiver Available

Hired by 1 family in your neighborhood

I really love working with Children. I have been babysitting for 6 years and have many references. I had an internship at an Elementary School in Greendale, WI as a teachers aid. I was in the 1st grade classrooms and I enjoy helping with school work. I am attending college and am majoring in Education. I hope that this will be a...
Alaina can also help with: Meal prep, craft assistance, swimming supervision, light cleaning
Skills:

First Aid

5.0
"Alaina is an outstanding caregiver at our church. she is ready to care for any children that she receives on a Sunday morning. She is bright and able to handle challenging situations with children. We love Alaina at Faith community Church."

Pastor Stu M.

Showing 1 - 20 of 60

Recent after school babysitter reviews from local parents in New Berlin, WI

Brittany B.

5.0

Brittany was great with my boys and she always cleaned up the house while watching the kids. I am sad that she moved away and will miss her! She is very reliable and truly great with kids!

- Laci M.

Alexis G.

5.0

Lexi is an AMAZING caregiver! She is quickly responsive, great communication, punctual, friendly, and helpful. She has watched our son a few times now and was so attentive and caring to him and his special needs! And he loves spending time with her so it makes getting out fun and easy. I would...

- Care member

Cam W.

5.0

Cam babysat for our two kids - 10 and 7. She was punctual and professional. Our kids enjoyed spending time with her and we would definitely hire her again!

- Care member

Katherine E.

5.0

Katie is very dependable and loyal babysitter. She's attentive to children of all ages. I have two children ages two and seven and they have loved her from the beginning and they always look forward to seeing her. She continuously encourages intellectual and emotional development with all children...

- Emily H.

Rachel R.

5.0

My wife and I have hired Rachel as a date-night sitter on multiple occasions for our three-year old daughter, and she also sat for us overnight while we were out of town once. We've worked with Rachel for about two years now, and definitely plan to continue working with her. Rachel is extremely...

- Timothy P.

Additional After School Babysitter Services

After School Babysitters in Waukesha, WIAfter School Babysitters in Hales Corners, WIAfter School Babysitters in Muskego, WIAfter School Babysitters in Big Bend, WIAfter School Babysitters in Elm Grove, WIAfter School Babysitters in Brookfield, WIAfter School Babysitters in Greendale, WIAfter School Babysitters in Pewaukee, WIAfter School Babysitters in Franklin, WIAfter School Babysitters in Butler, WI
After School Babysitters in Hillside, ILAfter School Babysitters in Monroe, WIAfter School Babysitters in Plymouth, WIAfter School Babysitters in Winneconne, WIAfter School Babysitters in Rockton, ILAfter School Babysitters in Freeport, ILAfter School Babysitters in Colgate, WIAfter School Babysitters in South Beloit, ILAfter School Babysitters in Oak Brook, ILAfter School Babysitters in Worth, IL
Show more

After School Babysitter Articles

Baby clothes sizes explained: How to shop at every month

April 2nd, 2025 It shouldn’t be complicated, but for some reason, baby sizes on clothing are unsettlingly confusing — particularly if you have no frame of refere... Read more
‘Call the Easter Bunny’ and more ways to make the holiday magical

‘Call the Easter Bunny’ and more ways to make the holiday magical

April 3rd, 2025 Easter is around the corner, and that means it’s time to break out the baskets, brightly colored eggs and … cell phones? In 2025, it’s eas... Read more
After-school restraint collapse: Why kids fall apart at home and what to do about it

After-school restraint collapse: Why kids fall apart at home and what to do about it

May 20th, 2024 Almost every parent or caregiver has been there: We meet kids at the school for pickup or greet them at the bus in the afternoon and within minutes, they&rsq... Read more
50 calm-down strategies for kids

50 calm-down strategies for kids

June 24th, 2024 Anyone who spends time with toddlers knows how challenging it can be to help a child work through a tantrum. You start to see the signs and dread the oncomin... Read more
Here’s why kids act out in front of other kids — and what to do about it

Here’s why kids act out in front of other kids — and what to do about it

July 27th, 2023 “I swear, they’re not normally like this. They’re so easy on their own! They were totally fine five minutes ago when it was just the two of... Read more

FAQs for finding an after school babysitter near you in New Berlin, WI

What types of after school babysitter services are available near me in New Berlin, WI?

How much does it cost to hire an after school babysitter near me in New Berlin, WI?

How can I find an after school babysitter near me in New Berlin, WI?

Can I hire an after school sitter near me in New Berlin, WI to watch my children between when they get off school and I get off work?

How can I safely find after school babysitters near me in New Berlin, WI?