Find After School Babysitters in Middle Island, NY
At Care.com, your trust and safety are our priority. Compare background-checked after school babysitters in Middle Island, NY and hire the best fit for your family.
Find after school babysitters in Middle Island, NY that you’ll love
60 after school babysitters are listed in Middle Island, NY
The average posted rate is $18/hr as of April 2025
The average experience for nearby after school babysitters is 3 years
After school babysitters in Middle Island, NY
5.0
(1)
Hired by 1 family in your neighborhood
I have 3 years of experience. I can help with Light Housekeeping and Errands. With me, your children will receive appropriate care and I am willing to do additional other tasks if requested. Personally, I'm an organizer and multitasker. With all my skills and experience, I'm able to provide a supervised and stable environment...
Kayla can also help with: Craft assistance, carpooling, grocery shopping, swimming supervision, light cleaning, meal prep & more
Skills:
CPR
First Aid
5.0
"Kayla is a very good sweetheart care giver she took care of my nephew a few times and he loves her definitely would love to have her back !"
Anthony R.
Hello my name is Cathy.
I have many years of experience of working in child care and previously worked at a day care before becoming a social worker. I worker 9-5 p.m. from home during the week and am looking to provide day care weekends and evenings during the week.
Catherine can also help with: Light cleaning, meal prep
Skills:
CPR
First Aid
Matt V.
Middle Island, NY
$18/hr • 2 yrs exp
I'm a dedicated childcare provider with a passion for nurturing and educating children. My journey into childcare began with fulfilling babysitting roles, where I discovered the joy of caring for little ones. Patience and calmness are my superpowers, enabling me to handle any situation with ease.
I believe in open and...
Matt can also help with: Meal prep
5.0
(2)
Hired by 4 families in your neighborhood
Hi there, I have two grown children of my own and can appreciate the importance of your endeavor. I have worked at a middle school for 10+ years helping children with special needs. I can assist with homework after school activities and play dates The school does background check so that should provide some extra peace of mind...
Karen can also help with: Travel, light cleaning, swimming supervision, carpooling, craft assistance
5.0
"Karen is a lovely woman. Never did we have to worry about someone not tending to our children. She was great with homework and keeping the kids occupied. My kids like to be outside playing and she was always up for anything. I never had to worry about texting and...
Kerri O.
5.0
(1)
Hired by 1 family in your neighborhood
Hello, my name is Tanya. I am an energetic mom of two grown children. I am retired with 20 years of service with the New York City Board of Education, working with the Universal Pre-K Program, as well as with the upper grades. After retiring, I knew that I had to return to what I do best and missed so dearly. I sought out and...
Tanya can also help with: Craft assistance, meal prep, carpooling, travel, swimming supervision, light cleaning & more
Skills:
Early Education
CPR
First Aid
5.0
"Tanya has been such a gift to our family. She started watching/teaching my 4-year-old son back in September 2020 after we decided to keep him home from preschool. I was able to work from home, but needed help watching and preparing him for kindergarten. We were so...
Stephanie K.
Jordan J.
Manorville, NY
$18-20/hr • 8 yrs exp
5.0
(3)
My name is Jordan! I am 26 years old and am a certified baby sitter having experience babysitting and nannying children for 8 years now. I am experienced in caring for children of all ages, and have cared for children from the ages of 7 months to 12 years old. I absolutely adore children and love being around them. I enjoy...
Jordan can also help with: Swimming supervision, craft assistance, travel, light cleaning, carpooling, meal prep & more
5.0
"Jordan is an awesome young lady. She is reliable and sweet. Caring and authentic
I recommend her wholeheartedly !!!"
Kathleen S.
5.0
(1)
Hired by 4 families in your neighborhood
I have worked with children since the age of 18. I am experienced in cooking, changing diapers, preparing meals, feeding young children, games and crafts, doing laundry and nap time. I can look after multiple children at the same time. I have also taken child development classes during high school and college. I come from a very...
Nicole can also help with: Light cleaning
Skills:
CPR
First Aid
Special Needs Care
5.0
"She is a wonderful babysitter. She was great with my 3 children. Caring, reliable and responsible. Also was very flexible with my changing work schedule. I would highly recommend her."
Christine H.
5.0
(1)
Hi! I am 18 years old and a college student looking to provide care to children. I love kids and I am ready to start as soon as possible providing care!
Maya can also help with: Swimming supervision, light cleaning, craft assistance, meal prep
Skills:
CNA
CPR
First Aid
Karen A.
Port Jefferson Station, NY
$25-35/hr • 10 yrs exp
5.0
(3)
Hired by 3 families in your neighborhood
Hi, my name is Karen. I'm an experienced childcare provider with over 30 years of experience. As a mother of three young adults, I'm passionate about supporting children's growth and creating a safe, nurturing, and fun environment. I'm available for part-time or occasional babysitting. Thank you for considering me. I look...
Karen can also help with: Light cleaning, swimming supervision, grocery shopping, meal prep, craft assistance
Skills:
CPR
Special Needs Care
First Aid
5.0
"Karen is dedicated, empathetic, and compassionate. She has always been flexible and accommodating. Anyone she cares for is so lucky to have her! She's a hard worker and great with my son."
Monica S.
Loren K.
Shoreham, NY
$17/hr • 8 yrs exp
5.0
(2)
I have been a care taker of children aged 3 months to 12 years for the past 8 years. I am glad to entertain and care for children at their home while their parents need help whether parents need an extra hand, or need a babysitter while they are gone. In the past, I have helped parents with getting their children to school, to...
Loren can also help with: Craft assistance, travel, swimming supervision
Skills:
Special Needs Care
CPR
First Aid
5.0
"Loren has been watching my girls for the past 5 years,2 girls, ages 5 and 7. She is extremely reliable and a great care giver. When she was away for semesters at school, my girls and I would anxiously await her return. I would HIGHLY recommend Loren. She is...
Gina W.
5.0
(4)
Hired by 1 family in your neighborhood
I am the mom of 2 grown boys. Love children. Know how hard it is to raise a family when parents need to work. I am very dependable and would love to help you. I retired from my job in the work force after 25 years and have been watching children the last few years. Let me know how I can help you. Thanks
Lori can also help with: Travel, carpooling, craft assistance
5.0
"Lori was wondeful with my children! She was always on time, and cared for my boys like her own. I couldn't thank her enough to have made it so easy to leave every day to go to work knowing my boys were being taken care of like I would care for them."
Tiffany B.
Jessica M.
Manorville, NY
$20/hr • 9 yrs exp
5.0
(1)
Hired by 3 families in your neighborhood
I have been a nanny since graduating college in 2017 and I have a background in a daycare setting working with infants and toddlers (ages 2 months- 3 years old). I am also a hockey coach for children of many ages. I am CPR certified, I am able to swim and I am very active. I love to be outside and do activities with kids that...
Jessica can also help with: Craft assistance, meal prep, swimming supervision, light cleaning, travel
Skills:
CPR
First Aid
Special Needs Care
5.0
"Jess is the best! I felt extremely comfortable around her/with her after only meeting her for a few minutes. She was amazing with my daughters from the moment she came into the house. She is great with children. My girls love her. We are so lucky to have found...
Alexandra C.
5.0
(1)
Hired by 1 family in your neighborhood
I am 41 years old. I am a very honest, dependable and caring person
Denise can also help with: Light cleaning, meal prep, grocery shopping
Skills:
CPR
5.0
"She was my perfect match. She was punctual, very polite and kind to my child. I would totally hire her again."
Martha S.
Jessica H.
Mount Sinai, NY
$20-30/hr • 7 yrs exp
5.0
(3)
Hired by 6 families in your neighborhood
Hi! My name is Jessica. I attended SUNY Cortland and received a degree in Childhood/ Early Childhood education. I am furthering my studies at Touro College to soon receive my masters degree in teaching English as a second language. I am currently a NYS certified teacher (birth through sixth grade). I have many years of...
Jessica can also help with: Carpooling, travel, swimming supervision, craft assistance
5.0
"Wonderful and Sweet Lady during the interview. (Side note: My dogs do not like anyone at first and they did not bark at her and allowed her to pet them on their tummies right away!) Would most certainly use Jessica's services on breaks from school."
Joanna Z.
Meghan B.
Coram, NY
$20-30/hr • 10 yrs exp
5.0
(1)
Hired by 1 family in your neighborhood
Hey! My name is Meghan and I am currently looking for a Full Time or Part Time nanny /House Manager/Personal Assistant position. I have my Bachelors of Science in Childhood Education and I am pursuing my Masters in Literacy. I have years of experience that include : local neighborhood babysitter, camp counselor, full time nanny...
Meghan can also help with: Craft assistance, light cleaning, swimming supervision, carpooling, travel
Skills:
Early Education
CPR
First Aid
5.0
"Meghan was amazing with both my boys (ages 2 and 7). Instantly, she connected w my 7 year old who gives everyone a hard time. Meghan's considerable experience teaching and tutoring has ingratiated her with families and kids of varying abilities and needs. She very...
Vera N.
5.0
(2)
Hired by 4 families in your neighborhood
I've never been a full-time nanny before but I've had years of experience babysitting and Id love to start full-time with children. I've been babysitting my younger brothers since I was 10 and I've had 3 years of experience babysitting other children. The youngest I've babysat is about 6 months old. I've never had any issues and...
Annarose can also help with: Carpooling, light cleaning, craft assistance, meal prep, swimming supervision
Skills:
First Aid
CPR
5.0
"Anna is super! We were worried our son wouldn't be okay with a completely new person, so we had her come the day before her official start date to get to know R. and make sure she was comfortable with our dog. R. warmed up to her almost immediately which isn't...
Shea R.
5.0
(1)
Hired by 2 families in your neighborhood
I am a junior in college who has 5 years of experience. I can help with travel, errands, homework, you name it! I have my own car and am willing to provide any transportation needed. I also have a part-time job where I work around people constantly and have volunteered regularly at the hospitals through school programs. I love...
Hanna can also help with: Carpooling, meal prep, swimming supervision, light cleaning
Skills:
CPR
First Aid
5.0
"I have 3 boys and have utilized Hanna for years, she has cared for my now 3 year old since he was a newborn and the others as young boys. She is "beyond her years" as far as dependability, punctuality, responsibility and the care she provides....and not to mention...
Rebekah L.
5.0
(1)
I like working with kids because I've always wanted to be that inspiring person for kids and be someone they feel comfortable opening up to and to be able to teach them things is so powerful. I also just enjoy the energy they bring.
I'm looking for a job that is flexible, I have a bit of a chaotic schedule so I need to...
Skills:
First Aid
CPR
5.0
"Courtney is a wonderful caretaker. She is always good with my 2 kids. She’s hardworking, genuine, kind, trustworthy. My kids absolutely adore her. We couldn’t ask for a better caretaker. "
Care member
4.0
(4)
Hired by 2 families in your neighborhood
Hello, my name is Tyler and I would love to babysit for you! I'm 20 and I have been babysitting since I was 12. I have my Associates Degree in General Liberal Arts and am continuing school in the fall. Please feel free to contact me at anytime!
5.0
"Always was available when needed.
Whenever I came home there was a craft that she did with the kids or something that they all baked together!
My children always enjoyed when she would come over to watch them!!"
Melissa L.
5.0
(3)
Hired by 7 families in your neighborhood
I am a retired elementary school teacher. I am CPR/AED certified. I taught a Pre-K readiness program and designed a Pre-K music and arts curriculum. I have experience with special needs children. I am also a CNA and Geriatric Specialist. I am experienced in private and institutional settings. I offer child care, and companion /...
Felicia can also help with: Carpooling, grocery shopping, meal prep, light cleaning
Skills:
First Aid
CPR
Early Education
5.0
" I absolutely love Felicia! She has been such a big help to our family. My daughter always looks forward to seeing Felicia every week. We trust her very much. We would highly recommend her! "
Liz B.
Showing 1 - 20 of 60
Recent after school babysitter reviews from local parents in Middle Island, NY
Kayla B.
5.0
Kayla is a very good sweetheart care giver she took care of my nephew a few times and he loves her definitely would love to have her back !
- Anthony R.
Karen D.
5.0
Karen is great! She cared for our 3 kids after school. She was always on time and helped manage unpacking, homework, and helping to straighten up. We also trusted her to drive them safely to and from activities.
- Carrie Y.
Tanya B.
5.0
Tanya has been such a gift to our family. She started watching/teaching my 4-year-old son back in September 2020 after we decided to keep him home from preschool. I was able to work from home, but needed help watching and preparing him for kindergarten. We were so blessed to find Tanya, who is warm,...
- Stephanie K.
Jordan J.
5.0
Jordan is a highly responsible young woman with whom I have left caring for my young children on many occasions. She is reliable and dependable. Jordan enthusiastically engages children and is very comfortable with them. I would highly recommend Jordan for a position.
- Katie T.
Nicole M.
5.0
She is a wonderful babysitter. She was great with my 3 children. Caring, reliable and responsible. Also was very flexible with my changing work schedule. I would highly recommend her.
- Christine H.
Additional After School Babysitter Services
After School Babysitter Articles
Can babies and kids go outside with a cold? Here’s what experts say
March 31st, 2025 Fresh air may be good for the soul, but should a toddler be going outside with a cold? What about taking a walk with a baby who’s got the sniffles? Or ... Read more
Easy jokes for kids of all ages
March 21st, 2025 Most kids are little clowns by nature, but learning how to tell a good joke is a skill that they will need help mastering. While your comedic chops may not r... Read more
6 qualities to help any daycare teacher shine
February 20th, 2019 I remember clearly the first time I dropped off my first child at daycare. I was so scared to leave him and worried he wouldn’t get the TLC he got at h... Read more
101 indoor games for kids and other activities
March 21st, 2025 When bad weather keeps kids (and their grown-ups) inside, boredom can quickly set in — but staying indoors doesn’t have to mean missing out on fu... Read more
What is nonbinary gender identity? How to explain to kids (and conscious adults)
March 21st, 2025 Gender diversity has always existed throughout cultures around the world, but in recent years, it’s become a more prominent topic of conversation in ou... Read more
FAQs for finding an after school babysitter near you in Middle Island, NY
What types of after school babysitter services are available near me in Middle Island, NY?
You can review 3 after school babysitter profiles near you in Middle Island, NY to get an idea of what types of babysitting services sitters in your area offer. For example, some after school babysitters may be comfortable picking up your children from school or cooking dinner for your family while your children do their homework at the kitchen table.
How much does it cost to hire an after school babysitter near me in Middle Island, NY?
The average hourly rate for after school babysitters near you in Middle Island, NY is $18.33. It’s worth noting that these rates can vary depending on years of experience and how many children you have, amongst other factors.
How can I find an after school babysitter near me in Middle Island, NY?
If you need after school care for your children, you can hire a babysitter who you can rely on to pick up your children from school or to meet them at your house when they get home from school. You can search for after school babysitters near you in Middle Island, NY on babysitting websites like Care.com.
Can I hire an after school sitter near me in Middle Island, NY to watch my children between when they get off school and I get off work?
Whether you work in the home or out of the home, you likely need care for your children for a few hours after school while you wrap up your work day. This is when hiring an after school babysitter near you in Middle Island, NY can really come in handy.
How can I safely find after school babysitters near me in Middle Island, NY?
We ask all after school babysitters on Care.com to complete an annual background check known as a CareCheck. If an after school babysitter completes a CareCheck, they have a badge on their profile that notes the date the background check was run. We strongly recommend you do your own due diligence to ensure you feel comfortable with the after school babysitter you hire by interviewing them, asking for references, and running an independent background check before you hire a sitter near you in Middle Island, NY.