Care.com logo
Child CareTutoringSenior CarePet CareHousekeeping

Find a job

Find after school babysitters in Lancaster, NY that you’ll love

60 after school babysitters are listed in Lancaster, NY

The average posted rate is $18/hr as of March 2025

The average experience for nearby after school babysitters is 5 years

After school babysitters in Lancaster, NY

Tammy N.'s Photo

Tammy N.


Lancaster, NY

$20-25/hr10 yrs exp

Looking For A Full-Time - Part Time

4.4

(5)

See profile

Hired by 8 families in your neighborhood

Hi , I am searching for a wonderful family to become their nanny ! I have enjoyed children ever since I was 16 and babysitting for the neighbors children. I have been caring and teaching children for over 20 years . I started out as an assistant teacher in a daycare . I cared for children of all ages and that's when I studied...
Tammy can also help with: Travel, carpooling, swimming supervision, meal prep, craft assistance, light cleaning & more
Skills:

First Aid

CPR

Special Needs Care

5.0
"Tammy was our nanny for 9 months. I was a first time mom with twins and although I was a stay at home mom, when my kids were 4 months old, I realized I needed some extra help. When Tammy was here, she was amazing! She was so loving and caring and the kids...

Karen L.

Morgan O.'s Photo

Morgan O.


Lancaster, NY

$20-30/hr5 yrs exp

Babysitter, Pet Sitter, Nanny

Hired by 1 family in your neighborhood

I have been a babysitter for almost all my life, taking care of siblings and neighbors around me. I am very patient, responsible and empathetic. I love children and pets. Seeing a smile on their faces brings joy to me.
Morgan can also help with: Carpooling, travel, craft assistance, swimming supervision
Maria C.'s Photo

Maria C.


Lancaster, NY

$20-32/hr10 yrs exp

Experienced Center Director With Over 20 Years Of Childcare Experience

Hired by 1 family in your neighborhood

I am currently a center director of a childcare center. I run the day to day operations and have on average 75 children under my care daily. I am CPR/first aid trained and MAT trained through NYS OCFS. I have traveled for nanny positions, taken children to after school activities and enjoy keeping up with household tasks such as...
Maria can also help with: Light cleaning, craft assistance, grocery shopping, carpooling, meal prep, travel & more
Megan P.'s Photo

Megan P.


Lancaster, NY

$18-30/hr8 yrs exp

Been caring for kids since I've been a kid! I started with Sunday School Service, to babysitting the kids on my street, to YMCA before and after school programs, to daycares, to now babysitting 18 month twin boys since they been 2 months. I love having a job where I can feel fulfilled, and being around kids is where I feel the...
Megan can also help with: Carpooling, travel, swimming supervision, craft assistance, light cleaning, meal prep & more
Skills:

First Aid

CPR

Hello, I am a mother of 3 boys who are now in their twenties. I also am a grandmother of 1 beautiful little girl and a boy on the way. I have a lot of experience raising three boys, one having epilepsy. I simply love children and helping them learn and grow at every stage of their lives. My strengths as a nanny Are that i'm...
Kimberlee can also help with: Grocery shopping, swimming supervision, light cleaning, craft assistance, meal prep
Skills:

CPR

First Aid

Molly M.'s Photo

Molly M.


Lancaster, NY

$19-50/hr1 yrs exp

Molly-

I'd describe my personality as Responsible, Fun and Flexible. I like working with kids because since high school I have always wanted to work with kids. I am good with kids, I am a patient and understanding person. I work at Maryvale Primary as a Teacher Aid and I have gained a lot of knowledge.
Tracy E.'s Photo

Tracy E.


Lancaster, NY

$16-50/hr6 yrs exp

My name is Kyla, I am 19 and I just finished my first year of college at Ithaca College, studying health sciences. I also run cross country and track for Ithaca. I have my own car, so I would have transportation. Also depending how you feel- I would be willing to drive to go places with the kids like the park or zoo or anywhere...
Kara H.'s Photo

Kara H.


East Amherst, NY

$16-20/hr5 yrs exp

Part-time Caregiver/babysitter

Hello! I graduated from SUNY New Paltz with a degree in Early Childhood/Elementary Education in May of 2019. I obtained my New York State Teaching Certification in June 2019 in Birth through Grade 6. I am currently attending Buffalo State College to get a masters in Special Education (1-6). I work for the Town of Amherst as a...
Kara can also help with: Light cleaning, meal prep, craft assistance, travel, swimming supervision
Skills:

First Aid

CPR

5.0
"Kara was a sweetheart! She was on time and made herself available in short notice. My two kids loved playing with her. I will definitely hire her again."

Elizabeth C.

Katie M.'s Photo

Katie M.


Elma, NY

$20-35/hr10 yrs exp

Hi! My name is Katie and I currently a building substitute in West Seneca. I am an inclusive childhood education major with a concentration in mathematics. I am certified in CPR and first aid. I have over 8 years of experience babysitting. I have worked with kids that are 1-month-old all the way up to 15-year-olds. I absolutely...
Katie can also help with: Meal prep, light cleaning, swimming supervision, travel, craft assistance
Skills:

First Aid

Special Needs Care

CPR

5.0
"Katie is the best to babysit kids. FUN, dependable, and a good role model. She turns an ordinary day into and extraordinary day."

Sally M.

Cherissa M.'s Photo

Cherissa M.


Buffalo, NY

$20-50/hr5 yrs exp

Hired by 7 families in your neighborhood

I started working with kids when I was super young. I would watch my nieces and kids around the neighborhood. I got my first daycare job at 16. I went to school and got my CDA in early childhood. I have been working at the summit center and absolutely love it! As lead teacher in the Summit Center I have the knowledge not only to...
5.0
"She is an awesome person and my baby loved her immediately! Thank you for your help"

Alaa A.

Katie M.'s Photo

Katie M.


Buffalo, NY

$20-30/hr20 yrs exp

Kind Katie, The Nurturing Nanny

Hired by 16 families in your neighborhood

I'd describe my personality as ambitious, authentic and easygoing. I like working with kids because no two days are the same, just how no two kids are the same. I love learning their personalities, likes/dislikes and how they think. It's extremely rewarding work and helping families by giving them a safe, caring option to...
Katie can also help with: Swimming supervision, grocery shopping, travel, carpooling, light cleaning, meal prep & more
Skills:

First Aid

Early Education

Special Needs Care

5.0
"Katie watched my daughter one evening, and as soon as my daughter woke up the next day, she was so excited to tell me about their adventures. Even though she only watched my daughter for four hours, in my daughter's mind, they had so much fun it was an all-day...

Harvey S.

Colleen C.'s Photo

Colleen C.


Buffalo, NY

$16/hr10 yrs exp

Occasional Sitter / Set Schedule Nanny

Hired by 1 family in your neighborhood

Hello! My name is Colleen! I am currently a student at ECC North Campus studying dental assisting and on occasion work at my job at a retail store. I am 23 years old and have been babysitting kids since I was 13. I don't have any children of my own but I have a 9-year-old niece and an 8-year-old nephew who I adore, along with...
Colleen can also help with: Meal prep, travel, swimming supervision, craft assistance
Skills:

First Aid

CPR

5.0
"Colleen is the best sitter I've ever had! She is very reliable and kind. I like how she engages with my children and doesn't sit on the couch with her phone. My kids loved her so much and was sad to her go."

Kaitlin C.

Merrick T.'s Photo

Merrick T.


East Aurora, NY

$20-30/hr6 yrs exp

Fun And Responsible Local Babysitter!

Hired by 2 families in your neighborhood

Hi, My name is Merrick! I started doing small babysitting jobs when I was 13 and since then have worked for 5 families as a serious nanny which has been on and off since 2020 according to the families needs. Each family I have worked with has at least 2 or more kids. I've also worked with special ed kids as well! Right now I am...
Merrick can also help with: Carpooling, light cleaning, craft assistance, swimming supervision, meal prep, grocery shopping & more
Skills:

CPR

First Aid

5.0
"Merrick is punctual, responsible and my boys have a lot of fun when she babysits."

Bethany W.

Brittany L.'s Photo

Brittany L.


Buffalo, NY

$25/hr10 yrs exp

Hired by 2 families in your neighborhood

Hi everyone! My name is Brittany, friends and family call me Brit! I've been in the caregiving profession most of my life, being the oldest cousin and sibling set me up for a natural affinity for taking care of others. I babysat for teachers, bosses and family friends up until and throughout a portion of nursing school. Upon my...
Brittany can also help with: Carpooling, meal prep, swimming supervision, craft assistance, travel, light cleaning & more
Skills:

First Aid

5.0
"Brittany is not only the best with all three of my kids including my son who is severely speech delayed, but she helps us so much around the house as well. She is kind, reliable and an amazing assets to our family. The kids love her and my weeks go so much...

Megan S.

Evelyn Q.'s Photo

Evelyn Q.


Buffalo, NY

$16-20/hr1 yrs exp

I have medical experience working with children. I am BLS and ACLS certified. I have over 4 years experience tutoring children in math, science and English. I am compassionate, attentive, dedicated and caring.
Evelyn can also help with: Travel, craft assistance
Skills:

CPR

Special Needs Care

First Aid

5.0
"Evelyn was prompt, warm, and very attentive to my son during our interview. She followed up our interview with a thoughtful email and showed initiative by looking up the answers to some questions that came up during our conversation. I needed a different...

Stephanie L.

Eleanor K.'s Photo

Eleanor K.


East Aurora, NY

$16/hr8 yrs exp

Hi! I am Ellee and I am 20 years old. I am a high school graduate and I am currently enrolled in an Occupational Therapy program. I have been babysitting outside of my home since the age of 12 and since I was 9 years old in my own home. I took the babysitting and child care certification class at my school. I have experience...
Eleanor can also help with: Craft assistance, light cleaning, swimming supervision
Skills:

Special Needs Care

5.0
"Ellee was always a wonderful help in assisting me with my twins with special needs. Always had a positive attitude, willingness to help whenever she possibly could & my family loved having her around! She has wonderful work ethics and would be a great asset to...

Amiee F.

Alexandra K.'s Photo

Alexandra K.


East Aurora, NY

$16-20/hr6 yrs exp

Fun Loving Babysitter With Flexible Hours :)

Hired by 3 families in your neighborhood

hi, my name is alex and i'm from east aurora. i'm 20 years old, graduated from east aurora high school in 2020 and now I am attending university in poland but am home for the summer. I was certified by the town as a babysitter in 2015, I have a car and a license if need be, along with experience taking care of children ages 1...
Alexandra can also help with: Swimming supervision, grocery shopping, meal prep, light cleaning, craft assistance, carpooling & more
Skills:

CPR

First Aid

5.0
"Alexandra is one of the best caregivers I have ever hired! She helped with remote schooling for my daughters, ages 9 & 11. She was always kind and patient with my daughter with special needs. Alexandra also kept my preteen off her phone 24/7 with baking and...

Rose P.

Andrea M.'s Photo

Andrea M.


Clarence, NY

$18-20/hr8 yrs exp

Part-time Babysitter

Hired by 1 family in your neighborhood

Hello! My name is Andrea. I am currently a School Counselor. I have had a handful of experiences working with toddlers, adolescents, and neuro divergent children/young adults. Previous jobs I have held were caring for a 3-month-old, babysitting for two little boys (3 and 8 years old), providing early intervention to 12...
Andrea can also help with: Craft assistance, meal prep, swimming supervision, grocery shopping, light cleaning
Skills:

Special Needs Care

CPR

First Aid

5.0
"We loved having Andrea watch our son! She watched him on recurring schedule and was always reliable and dependable. She was great with our 4 1/2 month old son. As a new mother, I felt completely comfortable leaving my infant with her. I would recommend her to...

Lindsay K.

Sarah B.'s Photo

Sarah B.


Buffalo, NY

$24-30/hr5 yrs exp

Hello! My Name Is Sarah.

Hired by 3 families in your neighborhood

Hi! My name is Sarah. I'm 24. I can be flexible with scheduling and have lots of experience in childcare. I did volunteer child care for my church and used to babysit throughout high school. Before attending college, I was a nanny for years working with several different families with children ranging in age from 13 days to 7...
Sarah can also help with: Light cleaning, swimming supervision, carpooling, meal prep, craft assistance
Skills:

First Aid

CPR

5.0
"Sarah is very kind and a dedicated employee. She does a great job of building relationships and can easily adapt to changes."

Jen F.

Allison R.'s Photo

Allison R.


Buffalo, NY

$15-20/hr3 yrs exp

Fun Sitter With Experience Working With Middle School Aged Children

Hired by 2 families in your neighborhood

Patient, loving, responsible and reliable nanny & babysitter! Loves outdoor activities, crafts, games, and educational tools! *disability knowledgeable*
Allison can also help with: Meal prep, craft assistance, light cleaning
Skills:

CPR

First Aid

5.0
"Ali is exceptional!! She is punctual, friendly, engaging and patient! She engages my girls while watching them and I feel confident leaving them in her care!"

Jessica S.

Showing 1 - 20 of 60

Recent after school babysitter reviews from local parents in Lancaster, NY

Tammy N.

5.0

Tammy was a pleasant addition to our household while caring for my son when I returned to work. He was two months premature and I felt confident leaving him in her care. She kept detailed notes of his daily feeding and sleeping schedule and he thrived under her watch. She was flexible with our ever...

- Caroline K.

Kara H.

5.0

Kara was a sweetheart! She was on time and made herself available in short notice. My two kids loved playing with her. I will definitely hire her again.

- Elizabeth C.

Katie M.

5.0

Katie is the best to babysit kids. FUN, dependable, and a good role model. She turns an ordinary day into and extraordinary day.

- Sally M.

Cherissa M.

5.0

Cherissa was so helpful today. She went above and beyond. My son immediately took to her and that means so much to me. I would definitely book her again.

- Care member

Katie M.

5.0

We hired Katie to watch our 10mo while we were visiting family for 2 weeks. She was extremely kind to our son (who loved her) and she was mindful of our wishes with respect to his care. She was very attentive and engaging with him during his wake windows (playing with toys, reading books, etc). She...

- Care member

Additional After School Babysitter Services

After School Babysitters in Depew, NYAfter School Babysitters in Elma, NYAfter School Babysitters in Clarence, NYAfter School Babysitters in Alden, NYAfter School Babysitters in Clarence Center, NYAfter School Babysitters in East Aurora, NYAfter School Babysitters in East Amherst, NYAfter School Babysitters in Getzville, NYAfter School Babysitters in Orchard Park, NYAfter School Babysitters in Corfu, NY
After School Babysitters in Seneca Falls, NYAfter School Babysitters in Kane, PAAfter School Babysitters in Dunkirk, NYAfter School Babysitters in Gasport, NYAfter School Babysitters in Webster, NYAfter School Babysitters in Warren, PAAfter School Babysitters in Gowanda, NYAfter School Babysitters in Le Roy, NYAfter School Babysitters in Naples, NYAfter School Babysitters in Big Flats, NY
Show more

After School Babysitter Articles

How to get CPR and first-aid certified

March 27th, 2024 It’s not fun to think about emergencies. But as much as you hope they’ll never happen, you do have to be prepared. CPR and first-aid are things ... Read more
Best exercises for kids (ages 5-12 years old)

Best exercises for kids (ages 5-12 years old)

February 12th, 2025 Kids need designated time each day to get out their wiggles and bump their heartbeats up a notch. According to the ... Read more
International Women’s Day for kids: How to explain the holiday to children of all ages

International Women’s Day for kids: How to explain the holiday to children of all ages

February 27th, 2025 Try this quick experiment with your kids: Without any context, ask them to name a handful of historic figures they’ve learned about recently in school. ... Read more
Restaurants where kids eat free (or super cheap)

Restaurants where kids eat free (or super cheap)

May 15th, 2024 After a long workday or busy weekend, sometimes the prospect of cooking for the whole family (and especially cleaning up) just sounds exhausting. But going ... Read more
Easy jokes for kids

Easy jokes for kids

April 11th, 2024 Most kids are little clowns by nature, but learning how to tell a good joke is a skill that they will need help mastering. While your comedic chops may not ... Read more

FAQs for finding an after school babysitter near you in Lancaster, NY

What types of after school babysitter services are available near me in Lancaster, NY?

How much does it cost to hire an after school babysitter near me in Lancaster, NY?

How can I find an after school babysitter near me in Lancaster, NY?

Can I hire an after school sitter near me in Lancaster, NY to watch my children between when they get off school and I get off work?

How can I safely find after school babysitters near me in Lancaster, NY?

Ratings for Lancaster, NY after school babysitters listed on Care.com

Average Rating4.0 / 5

After School Babysitters in Lancaster, NY are rated 4.0 out of 5 stars based on 5 reviews of the 60 listed after school babysitters.