Care.com logo
Child CareTutoringSenior CarePet CareHousekeeping

Find a job

Find after school babysitters in Islip, NY that you’ll love

60 after school babysitters are listed in Islip, NY

The average posted rate is $20/hr as of April 2025

The average experience for nearby after school babysitters is 6 years

After school babysitters in Islip, NY

Brigid M.'s Photo

Brigid M.


Islip, NY

$20-40/hr6 yrs exp

Reliable, Fun, And Trustworthy Nanny/babysitter!!

See profile

Hired by 2 families in your neighborhood

Hi, I'm Brigid! I am currently a substitute teacher for a K-2 school in Bay Shore, and am getting my masters at night! I am looking for part time after school babysitting job, as well as tutoring jobs!
Brigid can also help with: Swimming supervision, light cleaning, travel, meal prep, craft assistance, grocery shopping & more
Alyssa B.'s Photo

Alyssa B.


Islip, NY

$30-32/hr10 yrs exp

Love Children And Crafts!

5.0

(2)

Hired by 1 family in your neighborhood

I love taking care of kids, helping them learn and be creative. I am the youngest of three kids in my family so I really enjoy being around children since I was not around many growing up. I have over 13 years of experience as a babysitter, nanny, and lead infant teacher at a daycare. I am a hands on caregiver, I take kids to...
Alyssa can also help with: Meal prep, light cleaning, swimming supervision, craft assistance, travel, carpooling & more
Skills:

Early Education

First Aid

CPR

5.0
"Alyssa has been with us since our kids were babies. She’s become family, treating our children as if they were her own little sister and brother. She showers them with birthday gifts & thoughtful surprise gifts while away on her trips. On special holidays, she...

Care member

Mackenzie M.'s Photo

Mackenzie M.


Islip, NY

$25-30/hr10 yrs exp

Hired by 1 family in your neighborhood

Hi there I am Mackenzie! I have 10 years of experience with babysitting- from newborns to teenagers along with children with special needs. I can help with any Travel and Cooking/Meal Preparation that is needed. I am the oldest of 5 children along with being a full time substitute teacher. I am currently pursuing my Master's...
Mackenzie can also help with: Carpooling, travel, swimming supervision, craft assistance, light cleaning, meal prep & more
Skills:

Special Needs Care

Early Education

5.0
"I would highly recommend Mackenzie. She is kind, extremely caring. Very responsible and always punctual. I would absolutely trust her with my own children without question. Extremely sweet, and fun!!!"

Tracey G.

Bethany G.'s Photo

Bethany G.


Islip, NY

$14-25/hr1 yrs exp

Great Babysitter

I am currently attending college. I have babysitting experience for several years. I volunteered at my church Nursery for several years. I have worked and volunteered with Autistic children. I am a non-smoker and I have a clean driver's license.
Bethany can also help with: Light cleaning, meal prep
Skills:

First Aid

Hello! I am a working professional and am available for babysitting. I work from home and have a flexible schedule. I am very comfortable with pets. My ideal situation would be a long term gig during the day for one family with full-time hours but am open to other opportunities. I have been working in the higher education...
Nancy can also help with: Travel, swimming supervision, carpooling, craft assistance, meal prep, light cleaning & more
5.0
"Nancy is a godsend!!! She helped me with a lot of things at home. I have my elderly father who just started living with me, my furry kids and my daughter. She is always available to assist with an extra set of hands when I feel out numbered. I highly...

Nancy K.

Michael B.


Islip, NY

$17-18/hr1 yrs exp

Fun Aid Happy Sitter Compassionate To All Kids

I was a med student in the Caribbean . My school closed down. I am certified in basic life support and first aid emt pending . I am also a medical assistant , ekg tech. Phlebotomist. Taught as a teaching assistant at an allied health school.
Michael can also help with: Light cleaning, grocery shopping, meal prep
Skills:

First Aid

CPR

Karen D.'s Photo

Karen D.


Holbrook, NY

$25-30/hr8 yrs exp

Nanny/babysitter

Hired by 4 families in your neighborhood

Hi there, I have two grown children of my own and can appreciate the importance of your endeavor. I have worked at a middle school for 10+ years helping children with special needs. I can assist with homework after school activities and play dates The school does background check so that should provide some extra peace of mind...
Karen can also help with: Swimming supervision, carpooling, light cleaning, craft assistance, travel
5.0
"Karen is great! She cared for our 3 kids after school. She was always on time and helped manage unpacking, homework, and helping to straighten up. We also trusted her to drive them safely to and from activities."

Carrie Y.

Hailey C.'s Photo

Hailey C.


Bay Shore, NY

$17-25/hr5 yrs exp

Sitter

Hired by 1 family in your neighborhood

Caring fun loving sitter who offers patience, enjoys working with children, and is responsible. I am 24 yrs old and I currently work at huntington hospital. I have a 3-month-old babygirl at home. I have prior experience as a nanny for two younger boys ages 5 and 4 whom lost their mother. I helped the kids with homework and took...
Hailey can also help with: Swimming supervision, carpooling
5.0
"Hailey was very reliable! She was able to help us at the very last minute to watch our 6 year old and he loved her! Would def hire her again :)"

Larissa C.

Ashley S.'s Photo

Ashley S.


Bay Shore, NY

$17-25/hr10 yrs exp

EXPERIENCED TRUSTWORTHY & RELIABLE

Hired by 1 family in your neighborhood

Hello all! name is Ashley and I'm 23 years old. I am a NON-smoker! I am currently enrolled at New York Institute of Beauty to receive my Esthetics license this coming June of 2019. If you are looking for a trustworthy caregiver and positive influence on your child, I am the one for you! Some things you should know about me is I...
Ashley can also help with: Craft assistance, meal prep, carpooling, light cleaning, swimming supervision, travel & more
5.0
"Ashley Is ABSOLUTELY AMAZING!!!! And I Highly recommend Her! She is always and time and 100% Trustworthy"

Amber G.

Kayla S.'s Photo

Kayla S.


East Islip, NY

$17-20/hr4 yrs exp

I'm Extremely Patient With Kids And I Love Having Fun!

I have 3 years of experience. I can help with Swimming Supervision and Laundry. I love doing crafts and fun activities. I am extremely patient and good with children. I was a babysitter for 5 years now and a camp counselor for 6 years. I have a car and have been driving for 4 years now. I took a 2 year child development program...
Kayla can also help with: Swimming supervision, carpooling, craft assistance, meal prep, grocery shopping
5.0
"Kayla has an obvious love for children. She has been a date night sitter for me for the past 5 years. I always come home to a happy child who played games and made crafts! He is always happy when he hears Kayla is babysitting!!! I highly recommend her!"

Melissa C.

Jaime S.'s Photo

Jaime S.


Smithtown, NY

$17-20/hr7 yrs exp

Part-Time Caregiver Until Summer Then I Can Go Full-Time Lifeguard Also

My qualifications: -I've been a part-time babysitter since 2009 from ages 3-12. -I did full time babysitting last summer, ages 4-12. -I have experienced in babysitting special needs children. -I have been a certified lifeguard since 2010, also I am certified in CPR for all ages, certified in AED and First Aid. I student teach...
Jaime can also help with: Light cleaning, grocery shopping, swimming supervision, craft assistance, meal prep
Skills:

Early Education

First Aid

Special Needs Care

5.0
"Jaime applied to our summer child care job and came to meet the family in person. She was absolutely lovely! She called the day of the interview to confirm, showed up on time and bonded with our kids very quickly (despite the fact that my 10 year old son was angry...

Shawna A.

Dani S.'s Photo

Dani S.


West Islip, NY

$17-20/hr7 yrs exp

Part-time Caregiver

Hired by 4 families in your neighborhood

Need a date night babysitter or a after school babysitter? Growing up I watch kids in my neighborhood as their parents went out on date nights or had emergencies they needed to get to. I now help babysit my three nieces who are ages 9, 7, and 5. I lived in California for 6 months to work at PCDA as a Music Therapy Intern. As a...
Dani can also help with: Light cleaning, carpooling, swimming supervision
Skills:

First Aid

CPR

Katrina M.'s Photo

Katrina M.


East Northport, NY

$17-20/hr5 yrs exp

Hired by 1 family in your neighborhood

Hi, my name is Katrina! I am a college student majoring in early childhood education and am looking to spend my summer helping a family care for their young children. I have 5+ years of babysitting experience with varying ages, from infants to school age, including twins. I am responsible, caring, and conscientious and look...
Katrina can also help with: Light cleaning, craft assistance, swimming supervision
Skills:

CPR

First Aid

5.0
"Katrina worked full time with our family summer 2022. She was always on time, responsible and trustworthy. Most importantly my kids loved her and had so much fun with her, due in no small part to her connection and engagement with them. We were so grateful to have...

Liz C.

Kristine N.'s Photo

Kristine N.


Bay Shore, NY

$25/hr10 yrs exp

Family Day Care Provider

Hired by 1 family in your neighborhood

Dear Parents: I am a fun-loving, warm Licensed Family Daycare provider in my Bay Shore Home. Small group size lets me fill their day with painting, songs, giggles, dancing, storytelling, outdoor play! I have 28 years of experience. Serving ages 6 weeks thru age 4.
Kristine can also help with: Craft assistance
Skills:

First Aid

Special Needs Care

CPR

5.0
"I am beyond thankful that I found Kristine to care for my son for the past year (now 17 months old). I had planned on having my mom take care of my son when I went back to work but unfortunately she became ill and was no longer able to help care for him. I knew it...

Katie S.

Viviana A.'s Photo

Viviana A.


Ronkonkoma, NY

$24/hr4 yrs exp

Caring Babysitter

Hired by 1 family in your neighborhood

I'd describe my personality as caring, patient, and Kind. I like working with kids because I grew with 2 younger brothers and have been babysitting since the age of 15 and I've always found that I learn so much from working with kids and watching them grow. I'm looking for a job that is good at communicating what they...
Viviana can also help with: Light cleaning
Skills:

First Aid

CPR

Special Needs Care

5.0
"Viviana was the BEST! Our schedules had a conflict but our boys 3yrs and 1yr loved her. She really helped take a burden off our family even stepping in to help with dishes in the sink and folding laundry for time to time when the kids were settled to keep our...

Anthony M.

Gabriella D.'s Photo

Gabriella D.


Huntington Station, NY

$20-22/hr4 yrs exp

College Education Major Looking For A Summer Job.

Hired by 1 family in your neighborhood

Hi! I am a 19-year-old college student majoring in education. I have 4 years of experience. I have babysat for multiple families ages range from 0-13 years old. I also have worked at a day care during the summer. I have my own car and love spending time with children.
Gabriella can also help with: Grocery shopping, craft assistance, meal prep, light cleaning
5.0
"I had just given up on my hunt when Gabby reached out to me in regards to caring for my daughter and hiring her was the best decision. She was absolutely amazing w my girl and with in two weeks my girl was in love with her as well. I worked from home but heard...

Karen R.

Margaret K.'s Photo

Margaret K.


West Babylon, NY

$33/hr10 yrs exp

Loving Babysitter With Over 10 Years Of Experience Working With Children From Infants To School Age. I Am Available Full Time, Part Time And Weekends.

3.0

(1)

I am very focused and I take pride in working with the children I helped raise, some of whom are in college now. I have worked with children from infants to elementary school age children. I can assist with changing, bathing, feeding, homework, games, activities organizing/setting up of play dates and what ever the child's...
Margaret can also help with: Light cleaning, meal prep
3.0
"She told me she would call me to come by and meet my family and never called."

Linda D.

Erin K.'s Photo

Erin K.


Bay Shore, NY

$17-25/hr10 yrs exp

Part-Time Caregiver

Hello currently looking for a new position as a babysitting/nanny. I've worked with kids all my life and love doing so!
Erin can also help with: Carpooling, travel, craft assistance, light cleaning, meal prep, swimming supervision & more
Skills:

First Aid

CPR

Special Needs Care

Danielle R.'s Photo

Danielle R.


East Northport, NY

$10-15/hr7 yrs exp

Summer Babysitter In East Northport

Hired by 3 families in your neighborhood

Hi my name is Danielle and I live in East Northport. I graduated from the University of Scranton with my Bachelor's in elementary education and Masters in special education. I love working with children and have had many years of experience. Within the past six years I have babysat for multiple different families with varying...
Danielle can also help with: Travel, carpooling, light cleaning, swimming supervision, craft assistance
5.0
"We highly recommend Danielle as a babysitter. We hired her to watch our 2 yr old for 6 full days while we were visiting our parents on Long Island. She is trustworthy and dependable. She entertained my 3 yr old for long indoor days and got her to nap on time....

Megan B.

Alyssa G.'s Photo

Alyssa G.


Holbrook, NY

$17-20/hr6 yrs exp

Part-Time Babysitter

Hired by 6 families in your neighborhood

Hello! My name is Alyssa, I am 23 years old and an inspiring Social Worker! I have 2 years of childhood educational courses, 4 years of working in school childcare, and 8+ years working with families! I have babysat from newborn-12 years old. I also was a nanny for an infant until they were about 1 years old. I have worked...
Alyssa can also help with: Swimming supervision, travel, light cleaning, craft assistance
Skills:

CPR

First Aid

5.0
"she was such a lifesaver for us I was in a bind and sick and husband had a doctors appointment. Alyssa came and was so incredible with our 6 month old. she's on time, hardworking and so caring cannot wait to have her over again."

Kryssie S.

Showing 1 - 20 of 60

Recent after school babysitter reviews from local parents in Islip, NY

Alyssa B.

5.0

Alyssa has been with us since our kids were babies. She’s become family, treating our children as if they were her own little sister and brother. She showers them with birthday gifts & thoughtful surprise gifts while away on her trips. On special holidays, she comes up with meaningful crafts for the...

- Care member

Mackenzie M.

5.0

Mackenzie was great with our 3 kids. They all had a great time with her while mom and dad went out for a night and Mackenzie was excellent about communicating with us. Would definitely use her again and highly recommend!

- Jessica B.

Nancy K.

5.0

Nancy is a godsend!!! She helped me with a lot of things at home. I have my elderly father who just started living with me, my furry kids and my daughter. She is always available to assist with an extra set of hands when I feel out numbered. I highly recommend her to anyone. She has helped me...

- Nancy K.

Karen D.

5.0

Karen is great! She cared for our 3 kids after school. She was always on time and helped manage unpacking, homework, and helping to straighten up. We also trusted her to drive them safely to and from activities.

- Carrie Y.

Hailey C.

5.0

Hailey was very reliable! She was able to help us at the very last minute to watch our 6 year old and he loved her! Would def hire her again :)

- Larissa C.

Additional After School Babysitter Services

After School Babysitters in Bay Shore, NYAfter School Babysitters in Islip Terrace, NYAfter School Babysitters in East Islip, NYAfter School Babysitters in Brightwaters, NYAfter School Babysitters in Central Islip, NYAfter School Babysitters in Brentwood, NYAfter School Babysitters in Oakdale, NYAfter School Babysitters in West Islip, NYAfter School Babysitters in Islandia, NYAfter School Babysitters in Bohemia, NY
After School Babysitters in Leonardo, NJAfter School Babysitters in Baldwin Place, NYAfter School Babysitters in Springfield Gardens, NYAfter School Babysitters in Allendale, NJAfter School Babysitters in Stony Point, NYAfter School Babysitters in Westport, CTAfter School Babysitters in Greenwich, CTAfter School Babysitters in Ridgefield, CTAfter School Babysitters in Chappaqua, NYAfter School Babysitters in Verplanck, NY
Show more

After School Babysitter Articles

Can babies and kids go outside with a cold? Here’s what experts say

March 31st, 2025 Fresh air may be good for the soul, but should a toddler be going outside with a cold? What about taking a walk with a baby who’s got the sniffles? Or ... Read more
Easy jokes for kids of all ages

Easy jokes for kids of all ages

March 21st, 2025 Most kids are little clowns by nature, but learning how to tell a good joke is a skill that they will need help mastering. While your comedic chops may not r... Read more
6 qualities to help any daycare teacher shine

6 qualities to help any daycare teacher shine

February 20th, 2019 I remember clearly the first time I dropped off my first child at daycare. I was so scared to leave him and worried he wouldn’t get the TLC he got at h... Read more
101 indoor games for kids and other activities

101 indoor games for kids and other activities

March 21st, 2025 When bad weather keeps kids (and their grown-ups) inside, boredom can quickly set in — but staying indoors doesn’t have to mean missing out on fu... Read more
What is nonbinary gender identity? How to explain to kids (and conscious adults)

What is nonbinary gender identity? How to explain to kids (and conscious adults)

March 21st, 2025 Gender diversity has always existed throughout cultures around the world, but in recent years, it’s become a more prominent topic of conversation in ou... Read more

FAQs for finding an after school babysitter near you in Islip, NY

What types of after school babysitter services are available near me in Islip, NY?

How much does it cost to hire an after school babysitter near me in Islip, NY?

How can I find an after school babysitter near me in Islip, NY?

Can I hire an after school sitter near me in Islip, NY to watch my children between when they get off school and I get off work?

How can I safely find after school babysitters near me in Islip, NY?

Ratings for Islip, NY after school babysitters listed on Care.com

Average Rating5.0 / 5

After School Babysitters in Islip, NY are rated 5.0 out of 5 stars based on 9 reviews of the 60 listed after school babysitters.