Care.com logo
Child CareTutoringSenior CarePet CareHousekeeping

Find a job

How it works

Share details about your after school babysitter needs

Match with highly rated local after school babysitters near you

Compare after school babysitter options and choose the best fit

After school babysitters in Cicero, IN

JB

Julia B.


Noblesville, IN

$15-50/hr • 3 yrs exp

See profile

Hired by 1 family in your neighborhood

I've always loved working with children, and being a nanny has been a perfect fit for me. My goal is to help children thrive by providing a warm, nurturing, and engaging environment. I have three years of experience caring for children of all ages, and I'm comfortable caring for up to three children at a time. I'm patient,...
Julia can also help with: Grocery shopping, carpooling, meal prep, swimming supervision, travel, light cleaning & more

Nancy F.


Indianapolis, IN

$20/hr • 10 yrs exp

Nancy

5.0

(1)

Hired by 1 family in your neighborhood

Hello! My name is Nancy and I am a registered travel nurse from Indiana. I've worked as med/surg nurse for the past 6 years, and I have been babysitting since I was about 12 years old. I have about 8 weeks between my last assignment and a big vacation this summer, so I'm looking for babysitting jobs in New York City :) I spent a...
Nancy can also help with: Light cleaning, craft assistance, swimming supervision, meal prep
Skills:

First Aid

CPR

5.0
"We were thrilled with Nancy and would absolutely hire her again! She was on time, super friendly and immediately comfortable with our two 10-month old boys. She held them and played with them and I could tell she was paying careful attention to them, trying to make...

Mitch C.

Alexis D.'s Photo

Alexis D.


Indianapolis, IN

$18-50/hr • 10 yrs exp

Baby/ House/ Pet Sitter

Hired by 3 families in your neighborhood

I am a single, young professional looking to help out this holiday season! Open to pet/ house/ baby sitting. I have 4 years experience working at an after school care/ summer camp, 3 years experience with Big Brothers Big Sisters in Indy, and a love for animals!
Alexis can also help with: Craft assistance, carpooling, meal prep, swimming supervision, travel, light cleaning & more
5.0
"Extremely dependable, and quick to respond! I am very selective, and I feel very comfortable having my daughters in her care. Takes really good care of my 2 year old!"

Crystal G.

Selena K.'s Photo

Selena K.


Carmel, IN

$15-25/hr • 6 yrs exp

Experienced And Enthusiastic Sitter

Hired by 2 families in your neighborhood

I believe there is nothing more rewarding than caring for children. As an experienced babysitter/nanny and tutor I am not only able to look after your children but to provide them with a knowledge rich environment in which to grow. I have cared for children as young as 2 months and as old as 14 years. I am not only interactive...
Selena can also help with: Craft assistance, carpooling, light cleaning, meal prep, swimming supervision, grocery shopping & more
Skills:

First Aid

CPR

5.0
"Selena was professional, easy to schedule, and more than qualified to care for my 8 year old based on her extensive previous experience. She seems smart and sensible and like a good influence on my daughter. "

Care member

Olivia G.'s Photo

Olivia G.


Indianapolis, IN

$22-25/hr • 4 yrs exp

Fun Sitter, And Activity Enjoyer.

Hello i'm Olivia! I'm a college student working to become a paramedic (just finished emt trading), and a gymnastics coach of 4 years, during that 4 years I also assisted in running our after school program. I enjoy working with all different age groups and love being as busy and productive as possible.
Olivia can also help with: Light cleaning, craft assistance, travel, meal prep
Skills:

First Aid

CPR

5.0
"Super kind, very attentive, and a true sweetheart. She is very capable and affectionate with our 11month old son. Definitely worth a hire! Keep up the great work Olivia. :)"

Andrew G.

Chloe A.'s Photo

Chloe A.


Fishers, IN

$15-30/hr • 6 yrs exp

Part-Time Babysitter Available

Hired by 1 family in your neighborhood

Hello! My name is Chloe. I'm currently a home health aid for aging adults. I'm looking for some extra money as we approach the holiday season!
Chloe can also help with: Swimming supervision, carpooling
Skills:

First Aid

CPR

5.0
"I have known Chloe for 4 years as a friend and employee. She is a pleasure to be around. Her quick wit will bring a smile and laughter. She is great with my sons. I have a 8 and 10 year old son that live to be around her. She keeps them engaged and happy."

John B.

Abbi C.'s Photo

Abbi C.


McCordsville, IN

$14-30/hr • 7 yrs exp

Part-time Babysitter

Hired by 3 families in your neighborhood

Hi, I'm Abbi, 29 yr old, dog mom. I work in the fitness world as a coach at Orangetheory Noblesville. I work a few hours 4 days a weeks. Check my availability. I have time to help out with babysitting on occasion or set times per week. I have been babysitting for years, and I've worked with kids as a substitute for HSE...
Abbi can also help with: Craft assistance, carpooling, meal prep, swimming supervision, travel, light cleaning & more
Skills:

First Aid

CPR

5.0
"Abbi was great with our daughter. She was punctual, dependable, and played with our 1.5 year old daughter. "

Shelley Z.

Irene K.'s Photo

Irene K.


Carmel, IN

$15-20/hr • 10 yrs exp

Experienced, Reliable

I have been working with children in one avenue or another for over 30 years. I worked for Healthy Families as a parent-child interaction specialist, where I conducted developmental screenings for birth-3. I took a few years off to work on finishing my degree, and most recently ran an after school program in Noblesville for the...
Irene can also help with: Craft assistance, carpooling, light cleaning, meal prep, swimming supervision, grocery shopping & more
Skills:

Early Education

CPR

First Aid

5.0
"Irene has been my son's nanny for about nine months now. She is FABULOUS! She doesn't just "babysit" she teaches him important skills, letters, numbers, and encourages him to use more words vs pointing or just wining when he wants something. She is firm with rules...

Emily C.

Delaney M.'s Photo

Delaney M.


Indianapolis, IN

$25-35/hr • 5 yrs exp

Patient, Loving Nanny In Indianapolis

Hired by 2 families in your neighborhood

My first job ever was babysitting for many families in my neighborhood. As I got older, it continued to be something I loved to do. Many of my summer jobs during high school and college was nannying for families that I soon became a part of. After graduating college with a deeper understanding of children through social work and...
Delaney can also help with: Light cleaning, craft assistance, travel, meal prep
Skills:

First Aid

CPR

Special Needs Care

5.0
"Our family has had the privilege of knowing Delaney for over seven years. In that time, she has taken care of our home, our pets, but most importantly, our children. We have a son on the autism spectrum who can require extra understanding, but Delaney embraced...

Jill V.

Beth A.'s Photo

Beth A.


Whitestown, IN

$25/hr • 10 yrs exp

Babysitting/Errands/House Sitting/Pet Sitting

Hired by 4 families in your neighborhood

Hello families, I'm CPR certified up to date on my vaccinations and have excellent letters of recommendations along with email and numbers to contact the families. I'm a down to earth, responsible, reliable nanny that has a huge heart and I have a lot of love to give to your child/children. I have worked with newborns up to...
Beth can also help with: Meal prep, grocery shopping, travel, swimming supervision
Skills:

First Aid

CPR

5.0
"Beth has been caring for our son since he was 3 months old. She has been Nanny Beth to our son for almost a year and is an amazing kind, patient and loving caregiver. Beth takes direction well and easily adapts to changes in the home. Beth loves to read, go for...

Nina D.

Montana G.'s Photo

Montana G.


Zionsville, IN

$24-25/hr • 13 yrs exp

Hired by 4 families in your neighborhood

Hi there, thanks for stopping by! I'm Montana, a Cincinnati native, who moved to Indianapolis with my husband in May of 2017. Before moving, I received my bachelor's degree in Early Childhood Education and a minor in Child and Families from Miami University. I have 12+ years experience as an occasional day time and date night...
Montana can also help with: Grocery shopping, carpooling, meal prep, swimming supervision, travel, light cleaning & more
Skills:

Early Education

CPR

First Aid

5.0
"Montana is the best! We absolutely adore her. She babysits for my almost 1 year old and he loves her. She is punctual, dependable, confident, and just a joy to be around!"

Lindsey B.

Andy L.'s Photo

Andy L.


Carmel, IN

$15/hr • 3 yrs exp

Working Hard To Help Kids Grow!

I'd describe my personality as fun, a little loud, and creative! I like working with kids because I love to watch them grow into and be their own individual person. I am CPR and First Aid Certified. I have my own vehicle. I started working with kids shortly after I graduated high school! I was a preschool teacher and...
Andy can also help with: Craft assistance, carpooling, meal prep, swimming supervision, light cleaning
Skills:

First Aid

CPR

Special Needs Care

5.0
"We hired Andy to watch our two dogs all day for our wedding day, and my mind was completely at ease knowing Andy was there to take care of them. My dogs loved Andy!!! Andy was able to meet my dogs' needs, such as giving one of my dogs a pill with dinner, and...

Kyla P.

Emelia Q.'s Photo

Emelia Q.


Fishers, IN

$15-26/hr • 8 yrs exp

About Me

I have worked with children all my life professionally and have done babysitting gigs/house sitting. I have experiences with about all disabilities. I have worked as a caretaker for adults who have severe mental and physical disabilities. I have worked as a summer camp counselor, after school caretaker, babysitter/nanny (over...
Skills:

First Aid

CPR

Special Needs Care

5.0
"Emelia was an excellent caregiver to our daughter. She has a natural way of connecting with kids quickly and was a top tier communicator. We will be reaching back out to her any time the need arises."

Logan D.

Lisa V.'s Photo

Lisa V.


Carmel, IN

$20/hr • 10 yrs exp

Nanny/Babysitter

Hired by 6 families in your neighborhood

I am looking to fill Tuesdays and Thursdays 7-9 hours/day as I am already with another family on M, W and F. That family would be willing to provide a reference. I received my start as a caretaker for babies and toddlers as the oldest grandchild in a large family. I would go spend time at one of my cousins' houses as babies were...
Lisa can also help with: Craft assistance, carpooling, travel, swimming supervision
Skills:

First Aid

CPR

Special Needs Care

5.0
"Lisa is a wonderful caregiver! She watched my daughters and loved and cared for them like her own children. My girls are grown and still talk about how much they loved their time with her. Lisa provides a wonderful routine balanced with crafts, free play and...

Cheryl R.

Lexi J.'s Photo

Lexi J.


Carmel, IN

$22/hr • 10 yrs exp

Babysitter

Hired by 1 family in your neighborhood

Hello! I am Lexi, I am a 24-year-old who is just recently graduated from Indiana University. I grew up in a family of 3 siblings that are very athletic! So whether is sports practices or school work I'm here to help! I love being around children as I grew up in a large family with lots of siblings and cousins of all ages....
Lexi can also help with: Craft assistance, carpooling, light cleaning, meal prep, swimming supervision, grocery shopping & more
Skills:

First Aid

CPR

5.0
"Lexi is creative, fun, attentive, kind, and always reliable -- an ideal babysitter! My kids love to play with her, and she can handle anything that comes up."

Kerri R.

Madalynn W.'s Photo

Madalynn W.


Fishers, IN

$15/hr • 8 yrs exp

Hired by 12 families in your neighborhood

Hello, I have 7 years of experience ranging from 6 weeks-middle school age. I am CPR and first aid certified along with that I have my CNA and phlebotomy licenses, I also have the schooling for my LPN. I do hold a day time job which limits my availability to after work M-F and weekends. Due to my current job Monday through...
Madalynn can also help with: Light cleaning, carpooling, swimming supervision, travel, meal prep
Skills:

First Aid

CPR

5.0
"Madalynn is wonderful with my two boys. I still use her from time to time & highly recommend her for other families. "

Jodi G.

Kelsey F.'s Photo

Kelsey F.


Fishers, IN

$20-23/hr • 4 yrs exp

Meet Your Sitter !!

Hired by 4 families in your neighborhood

Multiple references available on request :) Hello! My name is Kelsey and I have 7 years of babysitting experience, 3 years of nanny experience. I believe nannying is one of the best jobs out there, and that connection with you get to have with the kids is precious and priceless. I love being able to be apart of all the...
Kelsey can also help with: Grocery shopping, carpooling, meal prep, swimming supervision, travel, light cleaning & more
Skills:

First Aid

CPR

5.0
"The kids had a great time hanging out with Kelsey! She was very flexible as well."

Care member

Lina M.'s Photo

Lina M.


Carmel, IN

$25-45/hr • 7 yrs exp

Warm-Hearted, Energetic, And Engaging Nanny/Sitter

I'm a patient and compassionate nanny/sitter with 7+ years of experience caring for children ages newborn to 14 years old. I'm highly skilled in infant care with extensive knowledge of safety precautions, in addition to specific feeding techniques and educational activities to stimulate physical, social and cognitive...
Lina can also help with: Craft assistance, carpooling, meal prep, travel, light cleaning
Skills:

First Aid

CPR

5.0
"Troylina took EXCELLENT care of my 15-month daughter when she needed to stay home from daycare at the last minute. Lina was reassuring, warm and nurturing with my daughter and extremely punctual, thorough, and helpful when communicating and planning with me. Would...

Sarah G.

Emily B.'s Photo

Emily B.


Carmel, IN

$10-20/hr • 7 yrs exp

Part-time Caregiver Available

Hired by 2 families in your neighborhood

I have been babysitting since I was 12 years old, when I completed the safe sitter course. I was a part of the peer facilitating program at Zionsville Community High School where I worked with elementary and middle school children on a daily basis. I have taught swim lessons to children and was a lifeguard where I was CPR, AED,...
Emily can also help with: Craft assistance, carpooling, swimming supervision, travel, light cleaning
Skills:

First Aid

CPR

5.0
"Emily is a very sweet young lady who genuinely enjoys children. I have 3 kids who adore her and are always asking when Daddy can take me out on a date again so Emily can come babysit. My kids enjoy playing with her and say she is very funny. She is always the first...

Tracy T.

Elizabeth S.'s Photo

Elizabeth S.


Carmel, IN

$13-20/hr • 4 yrs exp

Hired by 1 family in your neighborhood

Hi there! My name is Liz Schmidt! I will be a senior at IU this year and am studying Human Biology, on the Pre-Law track. As I study for the LSAT and complete an internship this summer, I would love to offer any assistance nannying or babysitting part-time! I love working with kids and furthering their learning and simply their...
Elizabeth can also help with: Light cleaning, carpooling, swimming supervision, meal prep
Skills:

First Aid

5.0
"Elizabeth did a wonderful job watching my grandsons. She was punctual, dependable and fun. I would hire her again in a heartbeat."

Lisa P.

Showing 41 - 60 of 60

Recent after school babysitter reviews from local parents in Cicero, IN

Nancy F.

5.0

We were thrilled with Nancy and would absolutely hire her again! She was on time, super friendly and immediately comfortable with our two 10-month old boys. She held them and played with them and I could tell she was paying careful attention to them, trying to make sure they'd be comfortable with...

- Mitch C.

Alexis D.

5.0

Extremely dependable, and quick to respond! I am very selective, and I feel very comfortable having my daughters in her care. Takes really good care of my 2 year old!

- Crystal G.

Selena K.

5.0

Selena was professional, easy to schedule, and more than qualified to care for my 8 year old based on her extensive previous experience. She seems smart and sensible and like a good influence on my daughter.

- Care member

Olivia G.

5.0

Super kind, very attentive, and a true sweetheart. She is very capable and affectionate with our 11month old son. Definitely worth a hire! Keep up the great work Olivia. :)

- Andrew G.

Chloe A.

5.0

I have known Chloe for 4 years as a friend and employee. She is a pleasure to be around. Her quick wit will bring a smile and laughter. She is great with my sons. I have a 8 and 10 year old son that live to be around her. She keeps them engaged and happy.

- John B.

Additional After School Babysitter Services

After School Babysitters in Atlanta, InAfter School Babysitters in Noblesville, InAfter School Babysitters in Westfield, InAfter School Babysitters in Tipton, InAfter School Babysitters in Sheridan, InAfter School Babysitters in Lapel, InAfter School Babysitters in Carmel, InAfter School Babysitters in Fishers, InAfter School Babysitters in Anderson, InAfter School Babysitters in Frankton, In

After School Babysitter Articles

Self-regulation strategies for kids and why it is an important skill to develop

April 10th, 2025 A 2-year-old sees a candy display at the grocery store checkout. He wants a chocolate bar, and his caregiver says no. A meltdown ensues. A few minutes later,... Read more
6 qualities to help any daycare teacher shine

6 qualities to help any daycare teacher shine

February 20th, 2019 I remember clearly the first time I dropped off my first child at daycare. I was so scared to leave him and worried he wouldn’t get the TLC he got at h... Read more
12 fun AANHPI Heritage Month activities for kids

12 fun AANHPI Heritage Month activities for kids

April 9th, 2025 Teaching kids about our nation’s rich diversity of heritages year-round is key to nurturing them to be compassionate and inclusive individuals. Asian A... Read more
24 funny Easter memes to make you happy

24 funny Easter memes to make you happy

April 9th, 2025 Whether you celebrate the holiday or not, funny Easter memes are still good for eliciting a laugh. Peeps. All the sugary treats. A giant bunny who delivers c... Read more
16 kids shows with LGBTQIA+ characters and storylines

16 kids shows with LGBTQIA+ characters and storylines

April 9th, 2025 Positive LGBTQ+ representation can be hard to find in media, especially when it comes to children’s entertainment. But it’s important for childre... Read more

FAQs for finding an after school babysitter near you in Cicero, IN

What types of after school babysitter services are available near me in Cicero, IN?

How much does it cost to hire an after school babysitter near me in Cicero, IN?

How can I find an after school babysitter near me in Cicero, IN?

Can I hire an after school sitter near me in Cicero, IN to watch my children between when they get off school and I get off work?

How can I safely find after school babysitters near me in Cicero, IN?